/

Kostryukov Andrey

Position of the Russian Church outside Russia as to the issue of holiness of Moscow Patriarchate in the period of metropolitan Filaret (Voznesensky)


Kostryukov Andrey (2021) "Position of the Russian Church outside Russia as to the issue of holiness of Moscow Patriarchate in the period of metropolitan Filaret (Voznesensky) ", Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Seriia II : Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoy Pravoslavnoy Tserkvi, 2021, vol. 98, pp. 130-142 (in Russian).

DOI of the paper: 10.15382/sturII202198.130-142

Abstract

This article is devoted to the attitude of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia to Moscow Patriarchate during the period Metropolitan Philaret (Voznesensky). During his years as head of the Russian Church Abroad, criticism of the actions of Moscow Patriarchate intensifi ed. The reason for criticism was the Patriarchate’s support for the Communist state, as well as its participation in the ecumenical movement. Metropolitan Filaret, who initially expressed his opinion with restraint, gradually changed his rhetoric. Partly, the Metropolitan’s sharpness was due to the infl uence of radicals, i.e. Protopresbyter George (Grabbe) (later Bishop Gregory) and Archimandrite Panteleimon (Metropoulos). The Councils and the Synod of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia also made harsh statements. In particular, it was said that Moscow Patriarchate cannot be considered the successor of His Holiness Patriarch Tikhon, and its orders are illegal. Attempts were made to declare Moscow Patriarchate unholy (Rus. безблагодатный, lit. ‘with no divine grace’). This opinion was expressed by the First Hierarch of the Russian Orthodox Church Abroad, Metropolitan Filaret (Voznesensky), as well as by the secretary of the Synod of Bishops, Protopresbyter George Grabbe. They believed that the holiness (Rus. благодать) of the cleric of Moscow Patriarchate can only be obtained at the moment of joining the Russian Church Outside Russia. Despite this opinion, the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia did not offi cially declare Moscow Patriarchate unholy. A large part of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia spoke of Moscow Patriarchate with respect and were ready for dialogue.

Keywords

Moscow Patriarchate, Russian Orthodox Church Abroad, Third All-Russian Council, holiness, sacraments, Metropolitan Filaret (Voznesensky), Archbishop Averky (Taushev), Archbishop Anthony (Bartoshevich), Protopresbyter George Grabbe, Archimandrite Panteleimon (Metropoulos), A. I. Solzhenitsyn

References

  1. Anashkin D. (2017) “K voprosu ob osobennostiakh bogosluzhebnoi zhizni Russkoi Zarubezhnoi Tserkvi v 1946–2000 gg.” [Characteristic features of liturgical life of the Russian Church Abroad in 1946–2000]. ХХVII Ezhegodnaia bogoslovskaia konferentsiia PSTGU, p. 164–172. Moscow (in Russian).
  2. Artemov N. (2008) “Sobesedovaniia predstavitelei klira dvukh germanskikh eparkhii (MP i RPTsZ) 1993–1997 gg. kak nachalo vosstanovleniia edinstva Russkoi Tserkvi” [Colloquys of representatives of the clergy of two German dioceses (Moscow Patriarchate and Russian Orthodox Church Abroad) in 1993‒1997 as the beginning of the restoration of the unity of the Russian Church]. XVIII Ezhegodnaia bogoslovskaia konferentsiia PSTGU, vol. 1, p. 302–324 (in Russian).
  3. Borisov A. (1994) Pobelevshie nivy. Razmyshleniia o Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi [Whitened fields. Refl ections on the Russian Orthodox Church]. Moscow (in Russian).
  4. Bochkov P. (2018) Obzor nekanonicheskikh pravoslavnykh iurisdiktsii ХХ–ХХI vv. [Review of non-canonical Orthodox jurisdictions of the 20th — 21st centuries]. St Petersburg (in Russian).
  5. Kornilov A. (2008) Monakh ot Optiny do Platiny. Zhizn’ episkopa Seattliiskogo Nektariia (Kontsevicha) [Monk from Optina to Platinum. The life of Seattle Bishop Nektarios (Kontsevich)]. Nizhnii Novgorod (in Russian).
  6. Makovetskii A. (2009) “Belaia Tserkov’”: Vdali ot ateisticheskogo terrora [White Church: far from atheistic terror]. St Petersburg (in Russian).
  7. Popov A. (2005) Rossiiskoe pravoslavnoe zarubezh’e [The Russian Orthodox expatriate community]. Moscow (in Russian).
  8. Psarev A. (2012) “Razvitie mirovozzreniya Russkoi Zarubezhnoi Tserkvi v otnoshenii Pomestnykh Tserkvei i inoslaviia” [Development of the attitude of the Russian Orthodox Church Abroad to local churches and non-Orthodoxy]. Deianiia IV Vsezarubezhnogo Sobora Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi Zagranitsei, p. 180–205. Moscow (in Russian).
  9. Sollogub A. (1968) Russkaia Pravoslavnaia Tserkov’ za granitsei: 1918–1968 [The Russian Orthodox Church Abroad: 1918–1968]. New York (in Russian).
  10. Slesarev A. (2009) Starostil’nyi raskol v istorii Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi (1924–2008) [Old-Calendar schism in the history of the Orthodox Church (1924‒2008)]. Moscow (in Russian)
  11. Senina T. (Kassia, nun) (2007) Stolp ognennyi. Mitropolit N’iu-Iorkskii i Vostochno-Amerikanskii Filaret (Voznesenskii) i Russkaia Zarubezhnaia Tserkov‘ (1964–1985) [Pillar of fire. Metropolitan Philaret of New-York and Eastern America (Voznesensky) and the Russian Church Abroad]. St Petersburg (in Russian).

Information about the author

Kostryukov Andrey


Academic Degree: Doctor of Sciences* in History;
Academic Degree: Candidate of Sciences* in Theology;
Place of work: St. Tikhon’s Orthodox University for Humanities; 6/1 Likhov Pereulok, office 219, Moscow 127051, Russian Federation;
Post: Leading Research Fellow, Research Centre for Contemporary History of Russian Orthodox Church; Associate Professor, Department of General and Russian Church History and Canon Law;
ORCID: 0000-0003-4334-1035;
Email: a.kost@mail.ru.

*According to the International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED) 2011, the degree of Candidate of Sciences (Cand.Sc.) belongs to ISCED level 8 — "doctoral or equivalent", together with PhD, DPhil, D.Lit, D.Sc, LL.D, Doctorate or similar.