Birkin Mikhail

Principles of formation of clerical identity in Isidore’s of Seville treatise On ecclesiastical offices

Abstract

This article studies the notion of the clergy of Isidore of Seville (ca. 560–636). The main source is the treatise “On Ecclesiastical Offi ces”, which was not studied from this point of view before. The article analyses the symbolic meaning of the tonsure, which received its place in canon law through the eff orts of Isidore, as well as his interpretation of the term clerus. By means of intertextual and comparative historical analysis, the article identifi es constituent elements of clergymen’s ethos, namely its relationship with early Christian communities and virginity, which does not completely correlate with celibacy. The main texts have been Octavius by Minucius Felix and On Holy Virginity by St. Augustine. Isidore especially stressed literacy and education among the essential features of the clergy. The author of the articles comes to the conclusion that all these elements are connected by the notion of the sacred status of the clergy, which was a prerequisite for the successful service to God and for the instruction of the fl ock.

Keywords

clergy, virginity, sacredness, ethos, Isidore of Seville, On Ecclesiastical Offi ces, Visigothic Kingdom of Toledo, Late Antiquity, Early Middle Ages

References

1. Afanasiev, Nicholas, protopriest (1971) Tserkovš Dukha Sviatogo [Church of the Holy Spirit]. Paris (in Russian).
2. Afanasiev, Nicholas, protopriest (1997) Ekkleziologiia vstupleniia v klir [Ecclesiology of the Entry into the Clergy]. Kiev (in Russian).
3. Albrecht Michael, von (2005) Geschichte der römischen Literatur. Von Andronicus bis Boethius. Mit Berücksichtigung ihrer Bedeutung für die Neuzeit. Vol. 3. Moscow (Russian translation).
4. Aurov Oleg V. (2004) «“Alço la mano, a la barba se tomo”: Iz istorii ispanskoi srednevekovoi pravovoi simvoliki» [““Alço la mano, a la barba se tomo”: From the History of Spanish Medieval Legal Symbolism”]. Centaurus. Studia classica et mediaevalia. 2004, vol. 1, pp. 125‒160 (in Russian).
5. Averintsev, Sergei S. (1977) “Simvolika rannego Srednevekovÿia (k postanovke voprosa)” [“The Symbolism in the Early Middle Ages: presentation of a problem”], in Iu. Ia. Barabash (ed.) Semiotika i khudozhestvennoe tvorchestvo [Semiotics and Artistic Creation], Moscow: Nauka, pp. 323‒334 (in Russian).
6. Barrow, Julia (2015) The Clergy in the Medieval World: Secular Clerics, Their Families and Careers in North-Western Europe c. 800 — c. 1200. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
7. Birkin, Mikhail Yu. (2017) “Ot grazhdanina k sviashchenniku: vita activa et contemplativa ot Avgustina Blazhennogo do Isidora Sevilšskogo” [“Isidore of Seville’s Ideas on Active and Contemplative Life: Background and Content”]. Vestnik drevnei istorii. Vol. 77/1, pp. 126‒139 (in Russian).
8. Bömer, F. (1952) “Pompa”, in A. Pauly, G. Wissowa, W. Kroll, K. Witte, K. Mittelhaus, K. Ziegler (Hsgb.) Realencyclopädie der Classischen Altertumswissenschaft. Stuttgart, Bd. XXI. 2, Sp. 1878–1994.
9. Burckhardt, Jacob (2013) Weltgeschichtliche Betrachtungen. Moscow; Saint Petersburg (Russian translation).
10. Bychkov, Viktor V. (1995). Estetika Ottsov Tserkvi. I. Apologety. Blazhennyi Avgustin [Aesthetics of Church Fathers. I. Apologists. St. Augustine]. Moscow (In Russian).
11. Cavallo, G., Chartier, R. (eds.) (2008) Histoire de la lecture dans le monde occidental. Moscow (Russian translation).
12. Cazier, Pierre (1994) Isidore de Séville et la naissance de l’Espagne catholique. Paris: Beauchesne.
13. Crouch, Jace (2010) “The Judicial Punishment of Decalvatio in Visigothic Spain: a Proposed Solution Based on Isidore of Sevilla and the Lex Visigothorum”. The Mediterranean Review, vol. 3/1, pp. 59‒81.
14. Dagron, Gilbert (2007) “Christliche Ökonomie und christliche Gesellschaft (8‒10 Jh.)”, in G. Dagron, P. Riche, A. Vauchez, E. Boshof (hrsg.). Die Geschichte des Christentums. Religion, Politik, Kultur — Mittelalter. Bd. 1: Bischöfe, Mönche und Kaiser (642‒1054). Freiburg, Basel, Wien, S. 256‒313.
15. Davidson, Ivor J. (2002) “Introduction”, in I. J. Davidson (ed.) Ambrose. De Officiis. 2 vols. Oxford: Oxford University Press, vol. 1, pp. 1‒112.
16. Faivre, Alexandre (1983) “Clerc/laïc: histoire d’une frontière”. Revue des Sciences Religieuses, t. 57, fasc. 3, pp. 195‒220.
17. Faivre, Alexandre (1977) Naissance d’une hiérarchie: Les premières étapes du cursus clérical. Paris: Beauchesne.
18. Fernandez, Alonso J. (1955) La cura pastoral en la Espana visigoda. Roma.
19. Finn, Thomas M. “It Happened One Saturday Night: Ritual and Conversion in Augustine’s North Africa”. Journal of the American Academy of Religion, vol. 58/4, 1990, pp. 589‒616.
20. Fontaine, J., Pellistrandi, C. (eds.) (1992) L’Europe héritière de l’Espagne wisigothique. Madrid.
21. García, Paredes Jose C. R. (1991) Teología fundamental de los sacramentos. Madrid.
22. Greenslade, Stanley L. (1956) “Ordo”. Scottish Journal of Theology, vol. 9/2, pp. 161‒174.
23. Gryson, Roger (1970) Les origines du célibat ecclésiastique: Du premier au septième siècle. Gembloux.
24. Gurevich, Aron J. (1973) “Narodnaia kul’tura rannego srednevekov’ia v zerkale «pokaiannykh knig»” [“The Early Medieval Popular Culture as Refl ected in «Penitential Books»”]. Srednie veka, vol. 37, pp. 38‒39 (In Russian).
25. Harris, William V. (1989) Ancient literacy. Cambridge, Harvard.
26. James, Edward (1984) “Bede and the Tonsure Question”. Peritia, vol. 9, pp. 85‒98.
27. Kerov, V., Sakharov, P. (2011) “Tonzura” [“Tonsure”], in Katolicheskaia entsiklopediia. Vol. 4. Moscow, col. 1407‒1408 (in Russian).
28. Lawson, Anthony C. (1938) “The Sources of the De ecclesiasticis offi ciis of S. Isidore of Seville”. Revue Bénédictine, vol. 50, pp. 26‒36.
29. Lawson, Christopher M. (1989) “Introduction”, in C. M. Lawson (ed.) Isidorus Hispalensis. De ecclesiasticis officiis. Turnhout, pp. 1‒163.
30. Lebedev, Alexei P. (1905) Dukhovenstvo Drevnei Vselenskoi Tserkvi (ot vremen apostol’skikh do 9 veka): Istoricheskie ocherki [Clergy of the Ancient Oecumenical Church from Apostolic Times to the 9th Century: Historical Essays]. Moscow (in Russian).
31. Lübker, Friedrich (1885) Reallexikon des klassischen Altertums für Gymnasien. St Petersburg (Russian translation).
32. Luchitskaia, Svetlana I. (2008) “Vvedenie” [“Intoduction”], in Odissei: chelovek v istorii. 2008: Script / Oralia: vzaimodeistvie ustnoi i pis’mennoi traditsii v Srednie veka i rannee Novoe vremia [Odysseus: Man in History. Script/Oralia: The Written and the Oral in the Middle Ages and Early Modern Time]. Moscow, pp. 7‒13 (in Russian).
33. Marey, Elena S. (2013) “Sapientiam sine eloquentia prodesse non est dubium: vzaimosviazÿ mudrosti i krasnorechiia v proizvedeniiakh Isidora Sevilÿskogo” [“Sapientiam sine eloquentia prodesse non est dubium: Relationship between Wisdom and Eloquence in Texts of Isidore of Seville”]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia I: Bogoslovie. Filosofiia. Religiovedenie, vol. 45, pp. 7‒19 (in Russian).
34. Marey, Elena S. (2018) “Sacerdos vs. Episcopus. Ispolšzovanie traktata «O semi tserkovnykh chinakh» Isidorom Sevilšskim (istochnikovedcheskiĭ aspekt)” [“Sacerdos vs. Episcopus. Employment of the Treatise De septem ordinibus ecclesiae by Isidore of Seville (A Source Study)”]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia I: Bogoslovie. Filosofiia. Religiovedenie, vol. 76, pp. 11‒22 (in Russian).
35. Markus, Robert A. (1985) “The Sacred and the Secular: From Augustine to Gregory the Great”. The Journal of Theological Studies, vol. 36/1, pp. 84–96.
36. Mazza, Enrico (1989) Mystagogy: A Theology of Liturgy in the Patristic Age. New York.
37. McCormick, Michael (1987) “Byzantium’s Role in the Formation of Early Medieval Civilization: Approaches and Problems”. Illinois Classical Studies, vol. 12/2, 1987, pp. 207‒220.
38. McGowan, Andrew (2014) Ancient Christian Worship: Early Church Practices in Social, Historical, and Theological Perspective. Michigan: Baker Academic.
39. McGowan, Andrew (1999) Ascetic Eucharists: Food and Drink in Early Christian Ritual Meals. Oxford.
40. Mills, Robert (2004) “The Signifi cation of the Tonsure”, in P. H. Cullum, K. J. Lewis (eds.) Holiness and Masculinity in the Middle Ages. Cardiff, pp. 109‒126.
41. Nakhov, Isai M. (1987) “Fiziognomika kak otrazhenie sposoba tipizatsii v antichnoi literature” [“Physiognomy as a Refl ection of the Typifi cation Method in Ancient Literature”]. Zhivoe nasledie antichnosti. Voprosy klassicheskoi filologii. 1987, vol. 9, pp. 69–89 (in Russian).
42. Nicolau, Miguel (1971) Ministros de Cristo: sacerdocio y sacramento del orden. Madrid.
43. Oexle, Otto G. (1990) “Stand, Klasse (Antike und Mittelalter)”, in R. Koselleck (Hrsg.) Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe, vol. 6, Stuttgart, pp. 156‒200.
44. Orlandis, Jose Ramos-Lisson Domingo (1986) História de los concilios de la España romana y visigoda. Pamplona.
45. Pellegrini, Pietrina (2008) Militia Clericatus Monachici Ordines: Istituzioni Ecclesiastiche e Società in Gregorio Magno. Catania.
46. Rhijn, Carine van (2016) “Manuscripts for Local Priests and the Carolingian Reforms”, in C. Rhijn, S. Patzold (eds.) Men in the Middle: Local Priests in Early Medieval Europe. Berlin, Boston, pp. 177‒198.
47. Sakharov, Stanislav A. (2011) “Osobennosti pravovogo statusa dukhovenstva v pozdnei Rimskoi imperii (po dannym «Kodeksa Feodosia»)” [“The Peculiarities of the Clergymen’s Legal Status in the Later Roman Empire (According to Codex Theodosianus)”]. Khristianskoe chtenie, vol. 5, pp. 158‒170 (in Russian).
48. Sánchez, Prieto Ana B. (2014) Rabano Mauro, Sobre la educación de los clérigos (De institutione clericorum): Alcance y penetración de la escuela carolingia. Tesis doctoral. Madrid.
49. Schmitt, Jean-Claud (1992) “La notion de sacré et son application a l’histoire du christianisme médiéval”. Les Cahiers du Centre de Recherches Historiques, vol. 9, pp. 19‒29.
50. Scholliers, P. (2001) “Meals, Food Narratives, and Sentiments of Belonging in Past and Present”, in P. Scholliers (ed.) Food, Drink and Identity: Cooking, Eating and Drinking in Europe Since the Middle Ages. Oxford, New York, pp. 3‒22.
51. Slyke, Daniel G. van (2005) “The Devil and His Pomps in Fifth-Century Carthage: Renouncing Spectacula with Spectacular Imagery”. Dumbarton Oaks Papers, vol. 59, pp. 53‒72.
52. Smith, Dennis E. (2003) From Symposium to Eucharist: The Banquet in the Early Christian World. Minneapolis.
53. Sotomayor, Muro M. (1979) “La Iglesia en la España romana”, in R. García-Villoslada (ed.) Historia de la Iglesia en España. Vol. I: La Iglesia en la España romana y visigoda: (s. I‒VIII). Madrid, pp. 7‒400.
54. Turner, Victor (1983) “The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure” (Russian translation), in Simvol i ritual. Moscow, pp. 104‒263.
55. Vilanou, Conrad (2003) “Literatura Cristiana i metafores esportives”. Revista Catalana de Teologia, vol. 28, pp. 457‒470.
56. Waszink, Jan H. (1947) “Pompa Diaboli”. Vigiliae Christianae, vol. 1, pp. 13‒41.
57. Winniczuk, Lidia (1988) Ludzie, zwyczaje, obyczaje starożytnej Grecji i Rzymu. Moscow (Russian translation).

Information about the author

Birkin Mikhail

Place of work: St. Tikhon’s Orthodox University for the Humanities; 6/1 Likhov Pereulok, Moscow 127051, Russian Federation;
Post: junior research fellow;
ORCID: 0000-0001-9224-7585;
Email: mbirkin@gmail.com.