Ozmitel Ekaterina

Central Asian pages of the biography of metropolitan Arseny (Stadnitsky): 1924–1936

Abstract

The article reconstructs the last period of the life of the outstanding bishop of the Russian Orthodox Church Arseny (Stadnitsky). As Metropolitan of Novgorod, he was sent into exile in Central Asia, where he eventually spent 12 years. The data found in the letters of Metropolitan Arseny to the lawyer A.F. Koni and in the writings of Bishop Andrei (Ukhtomsky), for the first time made it possible to determine the dates and places of residence of Metropolitan Arseny in Central Asia: he lived in Krasnovodsk from mid-1924 until the summer of 1925; in Poltoratsk (Ashgabat) – from August 28, 1925 until the spring of 1927, and then in Tashkent.There was a change in the course of church policy pursued by the Deputy Patriarchal Locum Tenens Metropolitan Sergius (Stargorodsky) in 1927. The attitude of Metropolitan Arseny to the new church policy was ambiguous. There are diametrically opposite opinions in the writings of church historians on this subject, therefore, it seemed important to determine the church-political views of Metropolitan Arseny on the basis of analysis of a large body of narrative sources (letters and memoirs). At first, this attitude was sharply negative. He did not break off communication with Metropolitan Sergius, did not criticize him publicly, but he fell into disgrace and was left in exile after its end. In 1933, Metropolitan Arseny, having accepted the appointment to the Turkestan department, returned to episcopal ministry and church administrative activities. He visited Moscow at least three times to participate in the sessions of the Provisional Patriarchal Synod. During this period, Metropolitan Arseny also had a negative attitude towards some actions of the highest church authorities, in particular, measures to exalt Metropolitan Sergius. Metropolitan Arseny did not hide this, but he did not publicly denounce anyone, fearing to strengthen the schism.The article makes a number of assumptions concerning the role played by the figure of Metropolitan Arseny in the question of the succession of the supreme church authority and in the plans of the OGPU, which sought the liquidation of the Russian Church. These hypotheses require further study on the basis of new documentary sources.

Keywords

Russian Orthodox Church in Central Asia, Turkestan Diocese, history of Orthodoxy in Tashkent, persecution of the Church in the Soviet Union, exiled clergy in Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan, Declaration of Metropolitan Sergius (Stragorodsky), church opposition

References

1. Balashova E. (2017) “K voprosu o sushchestvovanii õkatolicheskoi gruppy″ Vysoko-Petrovskogo monastyria (po materialam sledstvennogo dela 1935 g.)” [The problem of existence the “Catholic group” in Vysoko-Petrovsky monastery (drawing on the investigative case of 1935)]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia II: Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi, 2017, vol. 79, pp. 68–84 (in Russian).
2. Efremova O., Khailova O. (2006) “Kratkoe zhizneopisanie mitropolita Tashkentskogo i Turkestanskogo Arseniia (Stadnitskogo)” [Brief biography of Arseny (Stadnitsy), metropolitan of Tashkent and Turkestan], in Dnevnik. Vol. 1: 1880–1901. Po materialam GA RF [Diary. Vol. 1: 1880–1901. Using materials of the State Archive of the Russian Federation]. Moscow, pp. 29–62 (in Russian).
3. Fioletova N. (1992) “Istoriia odnoi zhizni” [History of one life]. Minuvshee, vol. 9, Moscow, pp. 7–105 (in Russian).
4. Gubonin M. (2007) “K kharakteristike nravstvennogo oblika mitropolita Arseniia (Stadnitskogo)” [Towards the characteristic of moral standards of Metropolitan Arseny (Stadnitsky)], in M. Gubonin (ed.) Sovremenniki o Patriarkhe Tikhone [Contemporaries’ views on Patriarch Tikhon]. Moscow, pt. 2, pp. 472–475 (in Russian).
5. Gubonin M., Mazyrin A. (priest) (2012) Kifa — Patriarshii Mestobliustitel′ sviashchennomuchenik Petr, mitropolit Krutitskii (1862–1937) [Kifa — St. Martyr Petr, Patriarchal Locum Tenens, Metropolitan of Krutitsy (1862–1937)]. Moscow (in Russian).
6. Krivosheeva N., Mazyrin A. (priest) (2015) “Arsenii (Stadnitskii Avksentii Georgievich), mitropolit”, in Za Khrista postradavshie. Goneniia na Russkuiu Pravoslavnuiu Tserkov’ 1917–1956: Biograficheskii spravochnik [Martyrs for Christ. Persecution of the Russian Orthodox church, 1917–1956. Biographical reference]. Book 1 (A). Moscow, pp. 607–612 (in Russian).
7. Mazyrin A. (priest) (2008) “Pomestnyi Sobor 1917–1918 gg. i vopros o preemstve patriarshei vlasti v posleduiushchii period (do 1945 g.)” [Local Council of 1917–1918 and the question about the continuity of the Patriarch’s authority in the following period (till 1945)]. Vestnik PSTGU. Ser. II: Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi, 2008, vol. 4 (29), pp. 35–51 (in Russian).
8. Mazyrin A. (priest), Sukhova N. (2009) “Nauchno-bogoslovskaia attestatsiia v period gonenii 1920–1930-kh gg. i prisvoenie uchenoi stepeni doktora bogosloviia mitropolitu Sergiiu (Stragorodskomu)” [Academic theological assessment in the period of persecution of the 1920s — 1930s and obtaining the degree of Doctor of Theology by Metropolitan Sergius (Stragorodsky)]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia II: Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi, 2009, vol. 3 (32), pp. 99–115 (in Russian).
9. Mazyrin A. (priest) (ed.) (2014) “…Na put′ sovershenno iskrennei loial′nosti k nashei Sovetskoi Vlasti″: Protokol uchreditel′nogo zasedaniia Vremennogo patriarshego sviashchennogo sinoda pri mitropolite Sergii (Stragorodskom)” [“...On the way of the fullest sincere devotion to our Soviet authorities”. Minutes of the inaugural meeting of the Temporary holy synod of Metropolital Sergius (Stragorodsky)]. Istoricheskii arkhiv, 2014, № 2, pp. 119–126 (in Russian).
10. Odintsov M. (2002) “Vysokopreosviashchenneishii Arsenii (Stadnitskii), mitropolit Tashkentskii i Turkestanskii (1862–1936)” [Very Reverend Arseny (Stadnitsky), metropolitan of Tashkent and Turkestan (1862–1936)]. Tserkovno-istoricheskii vestnik, 2002, vol. 9, pp. 109–145 (in Russian).
11. Odintsov M. (1999) Russkie patriarkhi XX veka. Sud′by Otechestva i Tserkvi na stranitsakh arkhivnykh dokumentov [Russian patriarchs of the 20th century. Fates of the motherland and the church in pages of archival records]. Moscow (in Russian).
12. Pavlov D. (2021) "Do smerti ia budu prizyvat′ vas k molitve″: Zhizn′ i sluzhenie mitropolita Guriia (Egorova) [“I will urge you to pray till my death”: Life and ministry of Metropolitan Guriy (Egorov)]. Moscow (in Russian).
13. Safonov D. (priest) (2019) Sviatitel′ Tikhon, Patriarkh Moskovskii i vseia Rossii, i ego vremia [St. Tikhon, patriarch of Moscow and all Russia, and his time]. Moscow (in Russian).
14. Vladimir (Ikim, metropolitan) (2018). Po stopam apostola Fomy. Khristianstvo v Tsentral′noi Azii [In the wake of Apostle Thomas. Christianity in Central Asia]. Moscow (in Russian).
15. Vorob′iev V. (priest), Shchelkachev A. (priest), Mazyrin A. (priest), Khailova O., Kazakov I. (2014) “Avvo moi rodnoi!″: Pis′ma sviashchennomuchenika mitropolita Kirilla (Smirnova) prepodobnomucheniku arkhimandritu Neofi tu (Osipovu) 1933–1934 gg.” [“Abba my dearest!”: Letters of St. Martyr Metropolitan Kirill (Smirnov) to St. Martyr Archmandrite Neofi t (Osipov), 1933–1934]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia II: Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi, 2014, vol. 2 (57), pp. 117–141 (in Russian).
16. Vorob′ev V. (priest), Kosik O. (2009) “Slovo Mestobliustitelia: Pis′ma Mestobliustitelia sviashchennomuchenika mitropolita Petra (Polianskogo) k mitropolitu Sergiiu (Stragorodskomu) iz Tobol′skoi ssylki i liudi, posluzhivshie poiavleniiu etikh dokumentov” [The word of the Locum Tenens: Letters of Locum Tenens St. Martyr Metropolitan Petr (Polyansky) to Metropolitan Sergius (Stragorodsky) from exile in Tobolsk, and the people who brought about these documents]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia II: Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi, 2009, vol. 3 (32), pp. 37–69 (in Russian).

Information about the author

Ozmitel Ekaterina

Academic Degree: Doctor of Sciences* in History;
Place of work: St. Tikhon’s Orthodox University for Humanities; 6/1 Likhov per., Moscow, 127051, Russian Federation;
Post: Senior Researcher in Research Centre for Modern History of Russian Orthodox Church;
ORCID: 0000-0002-3671-9493;
Email: k_ozmitel@rambler.ru.

*According to ISCED 2011, a post-doctoral degree called Doctor of Sciences (D.Sc.) is given to reflect second advanced research qualifications or higher doctorates.