Balyko Timofey

Development of the conservative opinions of the church in Orel diocese as to the freedom of conscience after the Missionary congress of 1901

Abstract

The article is devoted to the topic of freedom of conscience, which by the beginning of the twentieth century had become one of the main topics in Russian church and public thought. The relevant discussion was largely initiated by a speech in September 1901 at the Missionary Congress in Orel by the leader of the nobility of the Orel province, M. A. Stakhovich, who proposed introducing freedom of conscience in Russia and abolishing criminal penalties for falling away from the Orthodox Church. This event has been repeatedly considered in the context of the all-Russian controversy that has arisen, but the consequences of Stakhovich's speech in the Oryol diocese itself have not been subjected to scientific study before. The author of the article managed to establish the fact of the activation of conservative church thought in the Oryol diocese at the end of 1901 and the clear formulation of the positions of the Oryol conservatives on the introduction of freedom of conscience and other liberal freedoms, which were a threat to the existence of the church-state union and the Russian Orthodox state. Special attention in the study is paid to attempts to blur the boundaries of the Church in the Orel diocese, to include "random persons" acting on a political order in church life. It also drew criticism from conservatives. After 1901, the manifestation of church conservative thought in the Orel diocese on these issues can be traced in a number of journalistic materials. This concerns, first of all, the period of the revolutionary years 1905-1907. and 1917, which indicates a certain stability of church conservative ideas in the Oryol diocese, the presence of these ideas of groups of supporters who became active at crucial moments in history.

Keywords

freedom of conscience, Missionary Congress, M. A. Stakhovich, church conservative thought, Bishop Nikanor (Kamensky), Mitrofan of Athos, liberalism, Oryol Orthodox Peter and Paul Brotherhood

References

1. Balyko T. (2020) “Formirovanie predposylok obnovlencheskogo raskola v srede liberal′nogo dvorianstva i dukhovenstva Orlovskoi gubernii v 1900–1917 gg.” [Formation of prerequisites for the Renovationist schism among the liberal nobility and clergy of Orel province in 1900–1917]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia II: Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi, 2020, vol. 97, pp. 94–107 (in Russian).
2. Bendin A. (2010) “Svoboda sovesti ili veroterpimost′?: Polemika v rossiiskoi pechati (nachalo ХХ veka)” [ Freedom of conscience or religious tolerance? Polemics in the Russian press (the beginning of the 20th century)]. Novyi istoricheskii vestnik, 2010, no. 2 (24), pp. 5–14 (in Russian).
3. Gularian A. (2012) “M.A. Stakhovich: politicheskie vzgliady i obshchestvennaia zhizn′” [M. A. Stakhovich: Political views and public life]. Rossiiskaia istoriia, 2012, no. 2, pp. 184–192 (in Russian).
4. Dorskaia A. (2016) “Osobennosti vzaimodejstviia gosudarstva i lichnosti po voprosam svobody sovesti v otechestvennoi pravovoi traditsii” [Features of interaction between the state and the individual on issues of freedom of conscience in the Russian legal tradition]. Prava i svobody cheloveka i grazhdanina: teoreticheskie aspekty i iuridicheskaia praktika [Human and citizen rights and freedoms: theoretical aspects and legal practice]. Materialy ezhegodnoi Mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii pamiati professora Feliksa Mikhailovicha Rudinskogo [Materials of the Annual International Conference in the Memory of Professor Felix Mikhailovich Rudinsky], 2016, pp. 170–174 (in Russian).
5. Efimov A. (2007) Ocherki po istorii missionerstva Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi [Essays on the history of the missionary work of the Russian Orthodox Church]. Moscow (in Russian).
6. Kondakova L. (2019) “Episkop Mitrofan Afonskii (Orlovskie stranitsy zhizni)” [Bishop Mitrofan of Athos (life in Orel)]. Istoriia. Istoriki. Istochniki (elektronnyi nauchnyi zhurnal Tul′skogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta), 2019, no. 3, pp. 22–32 (in Russian).
7. Kurilov V. (2013) “Problemy prava na svobodu sovesti v Rossiiskoj imperii nachala ХХ veka” [Problems of the right to freedom of conscience in the Russian Empire of the early 20th century]. Nachalo: zhurnal instituta bogosloviia i filosofii, 2013, vol. 28, pp. 194–206 (in Russian).
8. Matiukhina O. (2014) Missionerskaia i prosvetitel′skaia deyatel′nost′ Orlovskogo Pravoslavnogo Petropavlovskogo Bratstva v 1887–1905 gg. [Missionary and educational activity of Orel Orthodox Peter and Paul Brotherhood in 1887–1905]. Vestnik KGU im. N. A. Nekrasova, 2014, vol. 20, no. 7, pp. 113–116 (in Russian).
9. Pavlova O. (2014) “Obsuzhdenie voprosa o svobode sovesti v ramkakh deiatel′nosti religioznofi losofskikh sobranii v Sankt-Peterburge v 1901–1903 gg.” [Discussion of the issue of freedom of conscience within the framework of the activities of religious and philosophical assemblies in St. Petersburg in 1901–1903]. Kul′tura. Dukhovnost′. Obshchestvo, 2014, no. 10, pp. 104–108 (in Russian).
10. Ponomariov A. (2012) “K voprosu o predostavleniiakh russkoi pravoslavnoi Tserkvi o pravakh i obiazannostiakh cheloveka v ХХ veke” [On the question of the Russian Orthodox Church’s provision of human rights and duties in the 20th century], in Pravovaia sistema sovremennoi Rossii: problemy i perspektivy ikh preodoleniia [The legal system of modern Russia: problems and prospects for overcoming them], 2012, pp. 31–36 (in Russian).
11. Rodnianskaia I. (2015) “Epizody zashchity svobody sovesti russkimi literatorami khristianskogo mirovozzreniia (ХХ vek)” [Episodes of the protection of freedom of conscience by Russian writers of the Christian worldview (20th century)]. Kul′turologiya, 2015, no. 4 (75), pp. 118–128 (in Russian).
12. Safonov A. (2007) Problemy svobody sovesti i veroispovedanii v obshchestvennykh diskussiiakh nachala ХIХ stoletiia [Problems of freedom of conscience and religion in public discussions of the early 20th century]. Izvestiia vysshikh uchebnykh zavedenii. Pravovedenie, 2007, no. 2 (271), pp. 203–211 (in Russian).
13. Shimanskaia O. (2001) “Svoboda sovesti v Rossii: istoriia, genezis, sovremennoe sostoianie” [Freedom of conscience in Russia: history, genesis, modern state]. Vestnik Nizhegorodskogo universiteta im. N.I. Lobachevskogo. Seriia: Pravo, 2001, no. 1, pp. 308–314 (in Russian).
14. Zhukova O., Kara-Murza A. (2011) “V bor′be za svobodu sovesti (o diskussii vokrug rechi M. A. Stahovicha na Missionerskom s»ezde v Orle 1901 g.)” [In the struggle for freedom of conscience (on the discussion around the speech of M.A. Stakhovich at the Missionary Congress in Orel in 1901)], in Orlovskii mudrets, operedivshii vremya [The sage of Orel, who was ahead of time], Orel, 2011, pp. 27–45 (in Russian).

Information about the author

Balyko Timofey

Student status: Graduate student;
Place of study: St. Tikhon’s Orthodox University; 23b, Novokuznetskaya st., Moscow 115184, Russian Federation;
ORCID: 0000-0001-6577-4320;
Email: t.balyko@yandex.ru.

Acknowledgments

To the priest, Professor, Deputy Head of the Department of the Modern History of the Russian Orthodox Church, Alexander Mazyrin