Filippov Boris

The Impact of Soviet-American Negotiations on the Change in Soviet Religious Policy (1985-1989): The Historical and Political Contexts of Gorbachev's Visit to the Vatican.

Abstract

This article deals with a radical change in the religious politics of the Soviet government between 1987 and 1988. Then, the celebration of the 1000th Anniversary of the Christianization of Rus’ became not only a Church issue but also an event of great political significance. Additionally, the official visit of Mikhail Gorbachev to the Vatican was designed in this period. The author argues that the communication problems which Gorbachev faced during his negotiations with Ronald Reagan in Geneva, Reykjav?k, and Moscow were the reason for this change. Since the anti-religious policy of the Soviet Union was one of the main obstacles to rapprochement between Reagan’s administration and the Soviet government, Gorbachev and his advisers decided to revise their approach to the Church issues. The author also assumes that Pope John Paul II unofficially played an important role in the negotiations between the US diplomats and the Soviet government. According to the article, the “Holy Alliance” between Reagan and Pope John Paul II had a significant impact on this negotiation process. Gorbachev’s visit to the Vatican was, in the author’s view, a link in the chain of events which led to the changes of Soviet religious politics. The legalization of the Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church was, according to the author, a price to pay for the normalization of the relationships both with the Vatican and with the USA. Based on recently published and unpublished sources, the author describes this process in a broad historical context and analyze the attitude of both the Russian Orthodox Church and the Holy See towards the Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church, religious freedom, and the role of religion in the public sphere.

Keywords

of the CPSU Central Committee Secretariat, Politburo, religious policy, reputation, trust, Holy Synod, "Holy Alliance", Vatican, Ukrainian Greek-Catholic Church, jubilee, freedom of religion, M. Gorbachev, R. Reagan, John Paul II, K. Kharchev, V. Falin, A. Casaroli, A. Chernyaev

References

1. Alekseev V. (1992) “Shturm nebes” otmeniaetsia? Kriticheskie ocherki po istorii bor′by s religiei v SSSR [“The assault on heaven is cancelled?” Critical essays on the history of struggle against religion in the USSR]. Moscow (in Russian).
2. Bernstein C. Cover Story: The Holy Alliance (Time, 24.02.1992), available at http://www.carlbernstein.com/magazine_holy_alliance.php (accessed 30.10.2020).
3. Bublyk T. (2014) “Problema greko-katolicheskoi identichnosti v Zapadnoi Ukraine v khode bor′by za legalizatsiiu (rubezh 1980–1990-kh gg.)” [The issue of the Greek-Catholic identity in the Western Ukraine during the struggle for the legalisation (late 1080s — early 1990s)]. Gosudarstvo, religiia, tserkov′ v Rossii i za rubezhom, 2014, no. 4, pp. 235–260 (in Russian).
4. Elenskii V. Religiia i perestroika v Ukraine [Religion and perestroika in the Ukraine], available at https://archipelag.ru/authors/elensky/?library=962 (12.05.2021) (in Russian).
5. Filippov B. (2021) “Il papa come catalizzatore dei cambiamenti: Giovanni Paolo II e la politica di informazione in URSS sulle questioni religiose”, in J. Mikrut (ed). Giovanni Paolo II e la chiesa cattolica in unione sovietica e nei paesi sorti dalla sua dissoluzione nel centenario della nascita di Karol Wojtyła (1920–2020) e nei Paesi sorti dalla sua dissoluzione Nel centenario della nascita di Karol Wojtyła (1920–2020). Verona, pp. 259–282.
6. Filippov B. (1989) “Ioann Pavel II: politicheskii portret” [John Paul II: political portrait]. Nauka i religija, 1989, no. 2, pp. 12–20 (in Russian).
7. Filippov B. (2019) “Leaving Socialism Behind: How Churches in the Post-Soviet Territories Adapted to a New Life in Russia and Poland”, in Latvij as Universitātes. Filozofi jas un socioloģij as institūts. Reliģiski-filozofiski raksti XXV. Riga, pp. 25–45.
8. Filippov B. (1988) “Mir v politicheskoi doktrine Ioanna Pavla II. Obzor” [The world in John Paul’s II political doctrine. An outline], in B. Filippov (ed.) Papstvo v sovremennom mire [Papacy in the contemporary world]. Moscow, pp.14–38 (in Russian).
9. Filippov B. (2013) “Papa, Pravoslavie, Ukraina” [Pope, Orthodoxy, Ukraine], in B. Filippov. Ioann Pavel II. Pol′sha. Politika [John Paul II. Poland. Politics]. Moscow, pp. 111–118 (in Russian).
10. Filippov B. (2016) “Ruzvel′t, Pii XII, I. Stalin i problema reputatsii SSSR v gody Vtoroi mirovoi voiny” [Roosevelt, Pius XII, Stalin, and the issue of the reputation of the USSR during World War II]. Vestnik PSTGU. Serij a II: Istoriia. Istoriia Russkoi Pravoslavnoi Tserkvi, 2016, vol. 4 (71), pp. 84–102 (in Russian).
11. Gordienko N. (1986) Kreshhenie Rusi: fakty protiv legend i mifov: polemicheskie zametki [Christianisation of Rus′: facts against legends and myths. Polemical notes]. Leningrad (in Russian).
12. Grinevskii O. (2004) Perelom. Ot Brezhneva k Gorbachevu [The fracture. From Brezhnev to Gorbachev]. Moscow (in Russian).
13. Ikonowicz M., Santini A. Papież w Moskwie. Wywiad, available at https://www.tygodnikprzeglad.pl/papiez-moskwie/ (accessed 22.07.2021).
14. Kengor P. (2011) Ronald Reagan. Duchowa biografia. Krakow.
15. Kharchev K., Achil′diev I. (1987) “Garantii svobody. Interv′ju” [Guarantees for freedom: an interview]. Nauka i religiia, 1987, no. 11, p. 23 (in Russian).
16. Klibanov A., Mitrokhin L. (1987) “Istoriia i religiia” [History and religion]. Kommunist, 1987, no. 12, pp. 91–98 (in Russian).
17. Koroleva L., Mel′nichenko O. (2011) “Prazdnovanie tysiacheletiia Kreshheniia Rusi: tserkovnoe meropriiatie ili obshchestvennoe sobytie?” [Celebration of the 1000th anniversary of the Christianisation of Rus′: a church action or a public event?]. Istoricheskie, filosofskie, politicheskie i iuridicheskie nauki, kul′turologija i iskusstvovedenie. Voprosy teorii i praktiki, 2011, no. 7, pt. 3, pp. 107–109 (in Russian).
18. Koroleva L., Mel′nichenko O. (2012) “Vlast′, Russkaia pravoslavnaia tserkov′ i Rimsko-katolicheskaja tserkov′ v Rossii (1985–2000 gg.): k voprosu o vzaimootnosheniiakh” [State authori ties, Russian Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholic Church in Russia (1985–2000): on the issue of relationships]. Vestnik KRASGAU, 2012, no. 2, pp. 222–226 (in Russian).
19. Kurliandskii I. (2011) Stalin, vlast′ i religiia (religioznyi faktor vo vnutrennei politike sovetskogo gosudarstva v 1922–1953 gg.) [Stalin, power and religion (religious factor in the internal policy of the Soviet state in 1922–1953)]. Moscow (in Russian).
20. Maslova I. (2015) “Gosudarstvenno-konfessional′naia politika v SSSR: povorot kursa v 1985–1988 gg.” [The policy of state towards religious denominations in the USSR: the change of strategy in 1985–1988]. Izvestija vysshikh uchebnykh zavedenii. Povolzhskii region. Gumanitarnye nauki, 2015, vol. 4 (36), pp. 43–54 (in Russian).
21. Massie S. (2013) Trust but Verify: Reagan, Russia, and Me. Rockland: Maine Authors Publishing. Mel′nichenko O. Gosudarstvo i RPC nakanune 1000-letiia Kreshcheniia Rusi [The State and the Church prior to the 1000th anniversary of Christianisation of Rus′], available at https://www.rusnauka.com/30_NNM_2010/Istoria/73003.doc.htm (27.03.2020).
22. Mitrokhin N. RPTs i ~uniaty″ v Zapadnoi Ukraine: mify i realii [Russian Orthodox Church and the “Uniates” in the Western Ukraine: myths and actual facts], available at https://religion.in.ua/main/analitica/3830-rpc-i-uniaty-v-zapadnoj-ukraine-mify-i-realii.html (17.04.2021).
23. Muren M. (1966) Vatikan i SSSR [Vatican and USSR]. Moscow (in Russian).
24. Musiewicz P. Ronald Reagan a Jan Paweł II. Kontekst ideowy i polityczny współpracy prezydenta i papieża, available at https://www.omp.org.pl/artykul.php?artykul=255 (13.05.2021).
25. Orlov A. Dnevniki Reigana [Reagan’s diaries], available at https://rusrek.com/news/eshhe/istoriya/30846-dnevniki-rejgana (12.04.2021) (in Russian).
26. Olszański T. (2013) Kresy Zachodnie: miejsce Galicji Wschodniej i Wołynia w Państwie Ukraińskim. Warszawa.
27. Polynov M. (2013) “Sovetsko-amerikanskie otnosheniia vo vneshnei politike M.S. Gorbacheva 1985–1988 gg.” [Soviet-American relations in Gorbachev’s foreign policy in 1985–1988]. Trudy Istoricheskogo fakul′teta Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta, 2013, no. 14, pp. 307–326 (in Russian).
28. Pospelovskii D. (1995) Russkaia pravoslavnaia tserkov′ v XX veke [Russian Orthodox Church in the 20th century]. Moscow (in Russian).
29. Preston A. (2012) The Sword of the Spirit, the Shield of Faith: Religion in American War and Diplomacy. New York: Knopf.
30. Raushenbakh B. (1975) Prostranstvennye postroeniia v drevnerusskoi zhivopisi [Spacial designs in the Old Russian painting]. Moscow (in Russian).
31. Raushenbakh B. (1987) “Skvoz′ glubinu vekov” [Through the depths of the centuries]. Kommunist, 1987, no. 12, pp. 99‒115 (in Russian).
32. Shveitser P. (1995) Pobeda. Rol′ tainoi strategii administratsii SShA v raspade Sovetskogo Soiuza i raspade sotsialisticheskogo lageria [The victory. Role of the secret strategy of the US administration in the collapse of the USSR and collapse of the socialist group of countries]. Minsk (in Russian).
33. Smolkin V. (2021) Sviato mesto pusto ne byvaet: istoriia sovetskogo ateizma [The holy place is never empty. History of Soviet atheism]. Moscow (in Russian).
34. Stremidlovskij S. Posol SShA v Vatikane rasskazala, kak papa i Reigan protivostoiali kommunizmu [US ambassador in the Vatical told how Pope and Reagan opposed Communism], available at https://regnum.ru/news/polit/2612901.html (accessed 11.07.2021).
35. Veigel′ G. (2001) Svidetel′ nadezhdy. Ioann Pavel II [The witness of hope, John Paul II]. Moscow (in Russian).
36. Zagorskii A. (2005) Khel′sinskii protsess [Helsinki process]. Moscow (in Russian).

Information about the author

Filippov Boris

Academic Degree: Candidate of Sciences* in History;
Place of work: St. Tikhon’s Orthodox University for Humanities; 23B Novokuznetskaia Str., Moscow 115184, Russian Federation;
Post: professor;
ORCID: 0000-0001-8250-3688;
Email: boris-philipov@yandex.ru.

*According to the International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED) 2011, the degree of Candidate of Sciences (Cand.Sc.) belongs to ISCED level 8 — "doctoral or equivalent", together with PhD, DPhil, D.Lit, D.Sc, LL.D, Doctorate or similar.