Isolated communities as a phenomenon of contemporary religious life
Ryazanova Svetlana (2021)
"Isolated communities as a phenomenon of contemporary religious life ",
Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta.
Seriia I : Bogoslovie. Filosofiia. Religiovedenie
pp. 119-135 (in Russian).
DOI of the paper: 10.15382/sturI202196.119-135
This study is devoted to the phenomenon of modern religious communities, which in the course of gradual evolution acquire the form of isolated from the outside world. The state of isolation is considered as a result of the infl uence of external and internal factors. Particular attention is paid to the personality of the leader of a religious group as a carrier of charismatic qualities and to their consolidating principle. The objects of research attention are two religious organisations that have existed for thirty years in the territory of Perm′ region (the Church of the God’s Family and the Intercession Fraternity). These groups realise two fundamentally diff erent ways of interpreting Christian doctrine and two diff erent strategies for living in a social space. At the same time, they are similar in the style of religious life and the principles of organisation of the followers. The aim of the study was to determine the mechanism for the formation of isolated religious communities in contemporary society. For this, the main stages in the evolution of the religious doctrines of both organisations were identifi ed to justify the opposition to the surrounding world; specifi c features of cult practice have been identifi ed, which reinforce the changes taking place in communities; a set of external factors that can stimulate the ghettoisation of a group have been identifi ed. Several types of information sources were used as fi eld materials. For the Church of the God’s Family the data from a longitudinal project (1996–2019) were used, covering the materials of the participant observations (1996–1997, 2007– 2008), data of a questionnaire survey (2007), data from interviews with leaders and members of the group (2007, 2018–2019), literature published by the church and the statutory documents of the organisation. For the reconstruction and analysis of the situation in the Intercession Fraternity, materials from a series of interviews with one of the founders of the community and former believers were employed. As additional and verifying materials, data from a closed group on a social network and data from journalistic investigations (2016–2019), audio recordings of community seminars and workbooks of the group were used.
modern religiosity, isolated religious communities, Family of God’s Church, Intersession Fraternity
- Akhmetova M. (2010) Konets sveta v odnoy otdel’no vzyatoy strane: Religioznye soobshchestva postsovetskoi Rossii i ikh eskhatologicheskii mif [The end of the world in one separately taken country: Religious communities of post-Soviet Russia and their eschatological myth]. Moscow: OGI; RGGU (in Russian).
- Asaulenko O. (2016) “Pod pokrovom t′my” [“Under the cover of darkness”]. The territory of Perm, July 11, pp. 3 (in Russian).
- Asaulenko O. (2017) “Grazhdanskii sud” [“Civil court”]. The territory of Perm, March 14, pp. 3 (in Russian).
- Asaulenko O. (2019) “«Po delam uznaete ih…»” [“By deeds you will know them ...”]. The territory of Perm, July 22, pp. 3 (in Russian).
- Balagushkin E. G. (1999) Netraditsionnye religii v sovremennoi Rossii. Morfologicheskĳ analiz [Non-traditional religions in modern Russia. Morphological analysis]. М: IFRAN (in Russian).
- Barker A. V. (1997) Novye religioznye dvizheniya: Prakticheskoe vvedenie [New religious movements. Practical introduction]. SPb.: Izdatel’stvo Russkogo hristianskogo gumanitarnogo instituta (in Russian).
- Beckford J. A. (1981) “Cults, Controversy and Control: A Comparative Analysis of the Problems Posed by New Religious Movements in the Federal Republic of Germany and France”. Sociological Analysis, vol. 42:3, pp. 249-264.
- Bella R. (1997) “Religiya kak simvolicheskaya model’” [“Religion as a symbolic model”]. Religion and Law, vol. 2–3, pp. 52–53 (in Russian).
- Beloded V. K. (1997) Slovo Materi Bozhiyey o velikom i slavnom deyanii Bozhestvennoy Premudrosti… [The word of the Mother of God about the great and glorious act of Divine Wisdom...] Issue 48. Perm: Society for Spiritual Education (in Russian).
- Campbell B. A. (1978) “Typology of Cults”. Sociological Analysis, vol. 39:3, pp. 228–240.
- Chesnokova V. Tesnym putem [Close way], available at: http://krotov.info/history/20/1990/chesnokova_00.htm (13.08.2011) (in Russian).
- Dobbelaere K. (2004) “Assesing secularization theory”, in New Approaches to the Study of Religion, Berlin, vol. 2, pp. 229-253.
- Filatov S. B., Lunkin R. N. (2005) “Statistika rossiyskoy religioznosti: magiya tsifr i neodnoznachnaya real’nost’” [“Statistics of Russian religiosity: the magic of numbers and ambiguous reality”]. Sociological research, no. 6, pp. 35-45 (in Russian).
- Grigor’eva L. I. (2002) Religii «Novogo veka» [Religions of the “New Age”]. Krasnoyarsk: Nauka (in Russian).
- Gurevich P. S. (1985) Netradicionnye religii na Zapade i vostochnye religioznye kul’ty [Non-traditional religions in the West and eastern religious cults]. Мoscow (in Russian).
- Hervier-Léger D. (2015) “V poiskakh opredelennosti: paradoksy religioznosti v obshchestvakh razvitogo moderna” [“In Search of Certainty: Paradoxes of Religiousness in Developed Modern Societies”]. State, Religion, Church in Russia and Abroad, no. 1 (33), pp. 254–268 (in Russian).
- Johnson B. (1992) “On Founders and Followers: Some Factors in the Development of New Religious Movements”. Sociological Analysis, vol. 53:S, pp. 1-13.
- Kaariainen K., Furman D. (2000) Staryye tserkvi, novyye veruyushchiye [Old churches, new believers]. Moscow (in Russian).
- Kanterov I. YA. (2006) Novye religioznye dvizheniya v Rossii. Religiovedcheskĳ analiz [New religious movements in Russia. Religious analysis]. Мoscow (in Russian).
- Kirichenko O. V. (2010) “Zhenskoye pravoslavnoye starchestvo v Rossii” [“Female Orthodox Eldership in Russia”]. Ethnographic Review, vol. 4, pp. 171-188 (in Russian).
- Konacheva S. A. (2001) “Religioznaya situatsiya v postsovetskoy Rossii: osobennosti protsessa sekulyarizatsii” [“Religious situation in post-Soviet Russia: features of the secularization process”], in: Stefanenko T. G. (ed.) Transformation of identification structures in modern Russia, Moscow: Moscow Public Science Foundation, pp. 82-105 (in Russian).
- Kormina J., Shtyrkov S. (2014) “Staritsa i smert’: zametki na polyakh sovremennykh zhitiy” [“Wise woman and Death: Notes on the Margins of Modern Lives”]. State, Religion, Church in Russia and Abroad, no. 1 (32), pp. 107-130 (in Russian).
- Mitrohin L. N. (1985) Religii «novogo veka» [Religions of the «New century»]. Мoscow (in Russian).
- Mitrokhin N. (2004) Russkaya pravoslavnaya tserkov’: sovremennoye sostoyaniye i aktual’nyye problem [Russian Orthodox Church: current state and topical problems]. Moscow: NLO UFO. (in Russian).
- Pokrovskaya obitel’. Za Veru, Otechestvo i drugim svoya [Intercession monastery. For Faith, Fatherland and others], available at: https://pokrovperm.ru/ (20.10.2020) (in Russian).
- (1996) Poyasnitel’naya zapiska k Ustavu Tserkvi-Sem’i Bozhiyey [Explanatory note to the Charter of the Church-Family of God]. Perm (in Russian).
- (2019) Pravoslavnaya obitel’ ili sekta: dve istorii permyakov, zhivshih v «Pokrovskoj obiteli» [Orthodox cloister or sect: two stories of Permians who lived in the Pokrovskaya cloister]. 59.RU, September 20 (in Russian).
- Robbins T., Anthony D., Richardson J. (1978) “Theory and Research of Today’s “New Religions””. Sociological Analysis, vol. 39, pp. 95–122.
- Robertson R. (1979) “Religious Movements and Modern Societies: toward a Progressive Problemshift”. Sociological Analysis, vol. 40:4, pp. 297–314.
- Ryazanova S. V. (1998) Dialog Zapada i Vostoka i fenomen neooriyentalistskikh kul’tov. Dissertatsiya na soiskaniye stepeni kandidata fi losofskikh nauk [Dialogue between the West and the East and the Phenomenon of Neo-Orientalist Cults]. Dissertation for the degree of candidate of philosophical sciences. As a manuscript. Perm (in Russian).
- Ryazanova S. V. (2019) “«Narodnoe bogoslovie» v cerkvi «Sem’ya Bozhiya»: syuzhety, obrazy, mify” [““Folk theology” in the church “Family of God”: plots, images, myths”]. Bulletin of PNIPU. The culture. History. Philosophy. Right, no.1, pp. 85-100 (in Russian).
- Sinelina Yu. Yu. (2014) “Dinamika religioznosti rossiyan. 1989-2012” [“Dynamics of Russians’ religiosity. 1989-2012”], in In memory of Yulia Yurievna Sinelina. Scientific works, memoirs, Moscow: ISPI RAN, pp. 146–168 (in Russian).
- Stone D. (1978) “New Religious Consciousness and personal religious Experience”. Sociological Analysis, vol. 39: 2, pp. 123– 134.
- Swatos W. H. (1981) “Church-Sect and Cult: Bringing Mysticism Back in”. Sociological Analysis, vol. 42, pp. 17–26.
- Wallis R. (1982) “The social construction of charisma”. Sociak Compass, XXIX/I, pp. 25–39.
- Wallis R. (1988) “Paradoxes of Freedom and Regulation: the Case of New Religious Movements in Britain and America”. Sociological Analysis, vol. 48:4, pp. 355–371.
- Wilson B. R. (1970) Religious Sects: A Sociological Study. McGraw-Hill.
- Wilson B. R. (2005) “Absolutes and relatives: two problems for new religious movements”, in Beckford J. A., Richardson J. A. (eds) Challenging Religion. Essays in honor of Eileen Barker, London; NY, рр. 11–20.
Information about the author
Ryazanova Svetlana Academic Degree:
Doctor of Sciences*
in Philosophy; Academic Rank:
Associate Professor; Place of work:
Perm’ Research Centre of Ural Branch of Russian Academy of Sciences; 15 Bukireva Str., Perm’ 614990, Russian Federation; Post:
leading research fellow, professor; ORCID: 0000-0001-5387-9387
*According to ISCED 2011, a post-doctoral degree called Doctor of Sciences (D.Sc.) is given to reflect second advanced research qualifications or higher doctorates.