/

Samarina Tatiana

Mysticism and the rational in R. Otto’s legacy


Samarina Tatiana (2020) "Mysticism and the rational in R. Otto’s legacy ", Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Seriia I : Bogoslovie. Filosofiia. Religiovedenie, 2020, vol. 90, pp. 68-84 (in Russian).

DOI of the paper: 10.15382/sturI202090.68-84

Abstract

This article addresses the legacy of Rudolf Otto, the most famous German phenomenologist of religion. First of all, it characterises his critics and shows that they all find the religious theory of R. Otto and his concept of mystical experience built around a religious experience that departs from rational schemes, which indicates its link to the psychological description of religious experiences by W. James. Further, referring to the works of R. Otto Kantisch-Fries’sche Religionsphilosophie und ihre Anwendung auf die Theologie: zur Einleitung in die Glaubenslehre für Studenten der Theologie (1909), Das Heilige (1917), and West-Östliche Mystik: Vergleich und Unterscheidung zur Wesensdeutung (1926), the article refutes claims of these critics. The article also examines Otto’s comparative analysis of the two mystics: the Indian philosopher Shankara and the German mystic Meister Eckhart. Otto observes that the numinous aspect, imposed on the metaphysical systems of Shankara and Meister Eckhart, turns the metaphysical systems into mystical. The article examines the methodological question of R. Otto if it is possible to speak of mysticism as a whole and discusses his division into two types, i.e. the mysticism directed inward, and mysticism directed outward. Besides, the article raises the question of to what extent it is possible to consider Otto a follower of F. Schleiermacher. It is concluded that Otto’s system cannot be called irrationalism; on the contrary, he sharply opposes all forms of irrational knowledge that reduce all religious life to emotions and experiences.

Keywords

phenomenology of religion, religious studies, comparative religion, mysticism, metaphysics, irrational, R. Otto, Shankara, M. Eckhart, I. Kant, J. Fries

References

  1. Barnes L. (1994) “Rudolf Otto and the Limits of Religious Description”. Religious Studies, 30 (2), p. 219‒230.
  2. Frolov A. (2011) “Germenevticheskie podstupy k Sviashchennomu R. Otto” [Hermeneutical approaches to the Sacred by R. Otto]. Filosofiia religii. Al’manakh 2010‒2011 [Philosophy of Religion: Almanac 2010‒2011]. Moscow. P. 429‒442 (in Russian).
  3. Isaeva N. (1991) Shankara i indiiskaia fi losofi ia [Shankara and Indian philosophy]. Moscow (in Russian).
  4. James W. (1993) The Varieties of Religious Experience. Moscow (Russian translation).
  5. Kant I. (1965) Die Metaphysik der Sitten. Moscow (Russian translation).
  6. King R. (2013) Orientalism and Religion: Post-Colonial Theory, India and “The Mystic East”. New York.
  7. Krasnikov A. (2007) Metodologicheskie problemy religiovedeniia [Methodological problems of religious studies]. Moscow (in Russian).
  8. Meister E. (1991) Predigten. Moscow (Russian translation).
  9. Meister E. (2001) Von Abegescheidenheit. Moscow; St. Petersburg (Russian translation).
  10. Nosachev P. (2018) “Mnogoobrazie misticheskogo: «mistika» i «mistitsizm» v zapadnom ezoterizme kontsa XIX — nachala XX veka” [The varieties of the mystical: “mystic” and “mysticism” in the Western Esotericism of the late 19th — early 20th centuries]. Filosofiia religii: analiticheskie issledovaniia, 2(1), p. 5‒29 (in Russian).
  11. Otto R. (1920) Das Heilige. Breslau.
  12. Otto R. (1926) West-östliche Mystik: Vergleich und Unterscheidung zur Wesensdeutung. Gotha.
  13. Otto R. (1936) The Idea of the Holy. London.
  14. Otto R. (1988) Aufsätze zur Ethik. München.
  15. Otto R. (2008) Das Heilige. St Petersburg (Russian translation).
  16. Pylaev M. (2000) Fenomenologiia religii Rudol’fa Otto [The phenomenology of religion of Rudolf Otto]. Moscow (in Russian).
  17. Pylaev M. (2006) Zapadnaia fenomenologiia religii [Western phenomenology of religion]. Moscow (in Russian).
  18. Schmidt E. (2013) “The Making of “Mysticism” in the Anglo-American World: From Henry Coventry to William James”, in The Wiley-Blackwell Companion to Christian Mysticism. Malden. P. 452‒472.
  19. Shokhin V. (2016) “Filosofskaia teologiia i promezhutochnaia versiia ishvaravady” [Philosophical theology and the intermediary version of Īśvaravāda]. Voprosy filosofii, 9, p. 138‒147 (in Russian).
  20. Shokhin V. (2017) “Real’nost’ i «zapakh real’nosti»: advaita na puti k stratifi katsionnoi ontologii. Shankara. Brakhmasutra-bkhash’ia. Chkhandog’opanishad-bkhash’ia”. Perevod s sanskrita i primechaniia V. Shokhina [“Reality and “a Smell of Reality”: Advaita on the Way to a Stratifi ed Ontology”, Shankara, “Brahmasutra Bhashya”, “Chandogyopanishad Bhashya”, translation and commentary by V. Shokhin]. Voprosy filosofii, 10, p. 182‒198 (in Russian).
  21. Shokhin V. (2018) “Opredeleniia misticheskogo: pervyi opyt ekspozitsii” [Defi nitions of the mystical: the first experience in their exposition]. Filosofiia religii: analiticheskie issledovaniia, 1 (1), p. 7–29 (in Russian).
  22. Stace W. T. (1961) Mysticism and Philosophy. London.
  23. Strenski I. (2015) Understanding Theories of Religion: An Introduction. Chichester, West Sussex, UK.
  24. Taves A. (2009) Religious Experience Reconsidered, A Building-Block Approach to the Study of Religion and Other Special Things. Princeton.
  25. Vysheslavtsev B. (1928) “R. Otto West-Ostliche Mystic”. Put’, 13, p. 106‒109 (in Russian).
  26. Waardenburg J. (2010) Reflections on the Study of Religion: Including an Essay on the Work of Gerardus van der Leeuw. Vladimir (Russian translation).

Information about the author

Samarina Tatiana


Academic Degree: Candidate of Sciences* in Philosophy;
Place of work: Institute of Philosophy Russian Academy of Sciences; 12/1 Goncharnaia, 109240 Moscow, Russian Federation;
ORCID: 0000-0002-9888-0872;
Email: t_s_samarina@bk.ru.

*According to the International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED) 2011, the degree of Candidate of Sciences (Cand.Sc.) belongs to ISCED level 8 — "doctoral or equivalent", together with PhD, DPhil, D.Lit, D.Sc, LL.D, Doctorate or similar.