Glushaev Aleksei

Schism in the Baptists’ Church: Initsiativniki and “Religious Extremism” in Interpretations of Soviet Atheistic Literature 1960–1980

Abstract

This article deals with a specific document base on the history of Evangelical Christians-Baptists in the USSR in the 1960–1980s, namely scientific-atheistic and propagandist literature. Employing several ideas of M.Yu. Smirnov and K.M. Antonov about the Soviet algorithm of work with religious material, the paper studies speech patterns and concepts which were used to interpret the activity of those Baptists who supported the Council of Churches of Evangelical Christians-Baptists. The adopted approach of source criticism allows us to disregard for the time being the issue of scientific value of the bulk of atheistic texts and to focus on those themes and plots that attracted attention of Soviet historians, sociologists of religion, as well as proponents of atheism who condemned supporters of church schism. The paper demonstrates that characteristic features of this phenomenon developed under the influence of political and legal evaluations of that time. Atheistic texts emphasised the illegitimate character of activities of Initsiativniki, blaming their authorities for anti-Sovietism and religious extremism. However, the Soviet treatment of Initsiativniki included a research dimension, due to which historical events were recorded and study methods of the schism within Baptism were enhanced. By the beginning of the 1990s, the Soviet antireligious discourse disappeared. The content of the terms “Initsiativniki”, “religious extremism” altered. However, if the name of Initsiativniki transformed into a historical term, religious extremism remains a concept imbued with negative connotations. The paper makes a conclusion about the topicality of critical study of antireligious discourse of the period from the 1960s to the first half of the 1980s.

Keywords

evangelical Christian-Baptists, AUCECB, Baptists, initiative group, Initciativniki, religious extremism, church schism, CCECB, atheistic literature, Soviet propaganda, ideology

References

Antonov K. M., “Ot dorevolyucionnoj nauki o religii k sovetskomu religiovedeniyu: stanovlenie ‘sovetskoj’ formacii diskursa o religii i sud’ba sistemy nauchno-issledovatel’skih programm”, in: Antonov K. M., ed., ‘Nauka o religii’, ‘Nauchnyj ateizm’, ‘Religiovedenie’: aktual’nye problemy nauchnogo izucheniya religii v Rossii XX – XXI v., Moscow, 2014, 27–58.
Bourdeaux M., Religious Ferment in Russia: Protestant Opposition to Soviet Religious Policy, London, 1968.
Brazhnik I. I., Social’naya sushchnost’ sektantskogo ehkstremizma, Moscow, 1974.
Brazhnik I., “Novoyavlennye apostoly baptizma v spekulyaciyah antisovetchikov”, in: Nauka i religiya, 12, 1969, 54–57.
Buzova T. V., Fenomen religioznogo ehkstremizma, Perm, 1989.
Filimonov Eh. G., Social’naya i ideologicheskaya sushchnost’ religioznogo ehkstremizma, Moscow, 1983.
Fletcher U., “Sovetskie veruyushchie”, in: Sociologicheskie issledovaniya, 4, 1987, 28–35.
Gal’perin B. I., Religioznyj ehkstremizm: kto est’ kto, Kiev, 1989.
Istoriya evangel’skih hristian-baptistov v SSSR, Moscow, 1989.
Klibanov A. I., Mitrohin L. N., Krizisnye yavleniya v sovremennom baptizme, Moscow, 1967.
Klibanov A. I., Reformacionnye dvizheniya v Rossii v XIV – pervoj polovine XVI vv, Moscow, 1960.
Klibanov A. I., Religioznoe sektantstvo i sovremennost’ (sociologicheskie i istoricheskie ocherki), Moscow, 1969.
Klibanov A. I., Religioznoe sektantstvo v proshlom i nastoyashchem, Moscow, 1973.
“Kto takie ‘iniciativniki’ u evangel’skih hristian- baptistov?”, in: Nauka i religiya, 7, 1966, 24–25.
Kurilov V. A., “Ponyatiya sekty, religioznogo ehkstremizma i klerikalizma v otechestvennyh issledovaniyah vtoroj poloviny XX – nachala XXI v.”, in: Vestnik Leningradskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta imeni A. S. Pushkina, 2, 2015, 221–229.
Lensu M. Ya., Kto takie “iniciativniki”?, Minsk, 1967.
Leshchinskij A. N., Pogasij A. K., “Tipologizaciya i klassifi kaciya cerkovnyh razdelenij v hristianstve”, in: Religiovedenie, 2, 2010, 91–101.
Lyalina G. S., Baptizm: illyuziya i real’nost’, Moscow, 1977.
Lyalina G. S., Novye tendencii v ideologii baptizma, Moscow, 1979.
Mitrohin L. N., Baptizm, Moscow, 1966.
Mitrohin L. N., Baptizm: istoriya i sovremennost’ (filosofsko-sociologicheskie ocherki), Saint-Petersbourg, 1997.
Nikol’skaya T. K., “Istoriya dvizheniya baptistov- iniciativnikov”, in: Al’manah po istorii russkogo baptizma, 3, 2004, 63–94.
Nikol’skaya T. K., Russkij protestantizm i gosudarstvennaya vlast’ v 1905–1991 godah, Saint-Petersbourg, 2009.
Plett I. I., Istoriya evangel’skih hristian-baptistov 1944–1990 gg. Posobie dlya biblejskih kursov, 2010.
Pogasij A. K., “Religioznye razdeleniya kak faktor mirovoj istorii (k voprosu o tipologii religioznyh raskolov)”, in: Religiovedenie, 4, 2009, 3–15.
Savinskij S. N., Istoriya evangel’skih hristianbaptistov Ukrainy, Rossii, Belorussii. CHast’ II (1917–1967), Saint-Petersbourg, 2001.
Smirnov M. Yu., “Religiovedenie v Rossii: problema samoidentifi kacii”, in: Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriya 7. Filosofiya, 1, 2009, 90–106.
Smirnov M. Yu., Religiya i religiovedenie v Rossii, Saint-Petersburg, 2013.
Stepanova R., Parahin A., “Neuvazhenie k zakonu neterpimo. Pis’mo v redakciyu”, in: Pravda, 19.02.1966, 2.
Trapeznikov S. P., Na krutyh povorotah istorii. (Iz urokov bor’by za nauchnyj socializm, protiv revizionistskih techenij), Moscow, 1972.
Yashin P. P., Krizis sovremennogo baptizma (O sushchnosti «novogo» raskola EKHB), Kharkiv, 1969.
Zavatski V., Evangelicheskoe dvizhenie v SSSR posle vtoroj mirovoj vojny, Moscow, 1995.
Zuev Yu. P., “Institut nauchnogo ateizma: istoriya deyatel’nosti i nauchnogo poiska (1964 – 1991 gg.)”, in: Svoboda sovesti v Rossii: istoricheskij i sovremennyj aspekty, 8, 2010, 268–289.

Information about the author

Glushaev Aleksei

Academic Degree: Candidate of Sciences* in History;
Place of work: Perm State Institute of Culture 18 Ul. Gazety Zvezda, 614000 Perm, Russian Federation;
Email: email: perst-ur@mail.ru.

*According to the International Standard Classification of Education (ISCED) 2011, the degree of Candidate of Sciences (Cand.Sc.) belongs to ISCED level 8 — "doctoral or equivalent", together with PhD, DPhil, D.Lit, D.Sc, LL.D, Doctorate or similar.