/ 
First Handbooks on History of Religion and Comparative Religion Abroad
DOI of the paper: 10.15382/sturI201663.101-116
Abstract
One of the important aspects of institutionalization of the religious studies in 1870– 1910s was the publishing of the fi rst handbooks on history of religion and comparative religion. The aim of the paper is to analyze methods and approaches of religious studies, as they described in these handbooks. The main characteristic of religion for the historians of religion was its universality. The most important methods, according to them, were historical approach, comparative approach, using of the notion «development». It is important, that we deal foremost with the «history of religion» in these handbooks, not with the «history of religions». Primitive religions were usually excluded from these handbooks, because they «have not history». First handbooks on history of religion often were edited in the series of theological handbooks, that’s why Christianity was described in them quite often as «higher» religion. Researches on comparative religion were based upon the history of religion. One of the main principles of comparative religion was that it should not deal with religious values, but only with a comparison of facts. The author concludes that scholars of religion nowadays should not only collect the facts, but also realize projects on the general history (theory) of religion.
Keywords
History of Religion, Comparative Religion, Religious Studies, Universality of Religion, Development of Religion, Methods of Religious Studies, Historical Method, Anthropology of Religion, Christianity
References
1. Antonov K. M. 2011 “Istoricheskoe izuchenie religii v duhovno-akademicheskoj tradicii v dorevoljucionnoj Rossii” (Historical Study of Religion in Spiritual-Academic Tradition in Russia before Revolution), in Vestnik PSTGU. Ser. 1: Bogoslovie. Filosofija, 2011, vol. 1/33, pp. 39–55.
2. Antonov K. M. 2011 “Kn. S. N. Trubeckoj i ego programma issledovanija religii v kontekste istorii otechestvennogo religiovedenija” (Prince S. N. Trubeckoj and His Religion Study Program in Context of History of Russian Religion Studies), in Tochki-Puncta, 2011, vol. 1–2/10, pp. 17–26.
3. Antonov K. M. Filosofija religii v russkoj metafizike XIX — nachala XX veka (Religion Philosophy in Russian Metaphysics of XIX — Begin of XX Century), Moscow, 2009.
5. 2006 “Istorija religii”, in Zabijako A. P., Krasnikov A. N., Zabijako E., Jelbakjan A. P. S. (eds.) Religiovedenie, Moscow, 2006, pp. 437–438.
6. Zabijako A. P. 2006 “Sravnitel'noe religiovedenie” (Comparative Religion Studies), in Religiovedenie, Moscow, 2006, pp. 1010–1012.
7. Zabijako A. P. 1991 “Sravnitel'noe religiovedenie: problemy i perspektivy”, in Vestnik MGU. Serija 7: Filosofija, 1991, vol. 2, pp. 35–42.
8. Krasnikov A. N. Metodologicheskie problemy religiovedenija (Methodological Problems of Religious Studies), Moscow, 2007.
9. Antonov K. M. (ed.) «Nauka o religii», «Nauchnyj ateizm», «Religiovedenie»: aktual'nye problemy nauchnogo izuchenija religii v Rossii XX — nachala XXI v. (“Religion Science”, “Scientific Atheism”, “Religion Studies”: Actual Problems of Scientific Religion Study in Russia in XX — Begin of XXI Cent.), Moscow, 2014.
10. Rahmanin A. Ju. 2013 “Istorija religii kak nauchnaja ideologija: k voprosu o nachal'nom jetape razvitija religiovedenija” (Religion History as Scientific Ideology: to Question about Primary Stage of Religion Studies Development), in Vestnik Russkoj hristianskoj gumanitarnoj akademii, 2013, vol. 14/2, pp. 85–94.
11. Shahnovich M. M. 2012 “L. Ja. Shternberg i «nauka o religii»” (L. Ja. Shternberg and “Religion Science“), in Lev Shternberg — grazhdanin, uchenyj, pedagog: K 150-letiju so dnja rozhdenija, Saint-Petersburg, 2012, pp. 190–199.
12. Shahnovich M. M. Ocherki po istorii religiovedenija (Essays on Religion Studies History), Saint-Petersburg, 2006.
13. Shternberg L. Ja. Pervobytnaja religija v svete jetnografii: Issledovanija, stat'i, lekcii (Primitive Religion in Light of Ethnography: Studies, Texts, Lectures), Moscow, 2012.
14. Jablokov I. N. 2011 “Religiovedenie i istorija religiovedenija: Diskussii v otechestvennoj literature“ (Religion Studies and Their History: Discussions in Russian Literature), in Religiovedenie, 2011, vol. 3, pp. 127–140.
15. Girardot N. J. 2002 “Max Müller’s Sacred Books and the Nineteenth-Century Production of the Comparative Science of Religion”, in History of Religions, 2002, vol. 41, pp. 213–250.
16. Sharpe E. J. Comparative Religion: A History, London, 1975.
17. Stausberg M. 2007 “The Study of Religion(s) in Western Europe (I): Prehistory and History until World War II”, in Religion, 2007, vol. 37, pp. 294–318.
18. Vasileva E. N. 2014 “Problems and Difficulties of Classifying Religions on the Basis of Confessional Differences”, in European Journal of Science and Theology, 2014, vol. 10/6, pp. 37–46.