Shokhin Vladimir

Philosophical Theology and Fundamental Theology

Abstract

Two theological disciplines are contrasted in this article: philosophical theology and fundamental theology. The former evolved in Great Britain and the United States and may be considered a type of philosophical and inter-cultural deepening of natural theology. The latter was developed principally in Western Europe and especially in German Roman Catholic schools as Fudamental-Theologie and deals mostly with theology from the standpoint of Christian apologetics. The contrast between the two types is based on the fact that each of them presents differing ways of theologia naturalis (with apology of theism at its heart), both entering the area of theologia revelata. This article is an attempt at mapping out the beginnings of an Eastern Orthodox philosophical theology as an innovative theological program. The author is therefore interested in examining exactly what constitutes such a philosophical theology and in defining the limits which Eastern Orthodox tradition necessarily places upon the evolution of such a system. He also tries to learn what past methodological discussions occurring in the environment of the Russian Orthodox theological schools can contribute to the development of such a system. The author argues that these contributions need to be confined merely to the courses offered by theological schools during the synodal period. Finally, the author wishes to define how philosophical theology and fundamental theology can relate to each other in spite of their theoretical differences. The fields of apologetics and hermeneutics would certainly profit from the development of the school of philosophical theology but exactly in what way remains a question for further research.

Keywords

Theology, Rational Theology, Revealed Theology, Natural Theology, Philosophical Theology, Fundamental Theology, Methodology, Apologetics, Hermeneutics, Argumentatio

References

1. Kant I. Gesammelte Schriften, Berlin, 1912, vol. 8.
2. Mac Donald S. “Natural Theology” in: Craig E. (ed.) The Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy, New York, 1998, vol. 6, pp. 711–712.
3. Pummer R. “Religionswissenschaft or Religiology?” in: Numen, 1972, vol. 19, pp. 91–127.
4. Schrödter W. “Religion bzw. Theologie, natürliche bzw, vernünftige” in: Ritter J., Gründer K. (ed.) Historisches Wörterbuch der Philosophie, 1992, vol. 8, pp. 714–715.
5. Shokhin V. “Philosophy of Religion and Varieties of Rational Theology” in: Bradshaw D. (ed.) Philosophical Theology and the Christian Tradition: Russian and Western Perspectives, Washington (DC), 2012, pp. 5–20.
6. Tennant F. R. Philosophical Theology, Cambridge, 1928–1930, vol. 1–2.
7. Wagner H. “Fungamentaltheologie” in: Kraue G., Müller G. (eds.) Theologiche Realenzylkopädie, Berlin, 1983, vol. 11, pp. 741–751.
8. Antonov K. M. “Istoricheskoe izuchenie religii v duhovno-akademicheskoj tradicii v dorevoljucionnoj Rossii” (Historical Research of the Religion in Theological Academic Tradition in Prerevolutionary Russia) in: Vestnik PSTGU. Ser. I: Bogoslovie. Filosofija, 2011, vol. 1 (33), pp. 42–46.
9. Glagolev S. S. Posobie k izucheniju osnovnogo bogoslovija. Zhenskie bogoslovskie kursy (Manual for Study of Systematic Theology. Female Theological Courses), Moscow, 1912.
10. Golubcov S. A. Moskovskaja duhovnaja akademija v revoljucionnuju jepohu. Akademija v social'nom dvizhenii i sluzhenii v nachale XX veka (Moscow Theological Academy in Revolutionary Epoch. Academy in Social Movement and Service in the Beginning of the 20th Century), Moscow, 1999.
11. Avgustin (Guljanickij), arhim. Rukovodstvo k osnovnomu bogosloviju (Manual for Systematic Theology), Vilnius, 1876.
12. Dobrotvorskij V., prot. Osnovnoe bogoslovie, ili Hristianskaja apologetika. Pravoslavnoe dogmaticheskoe bogoslovie: Lekcii (Systematic Theology or Christian Apologetics. Orthodox Dogmatic Theology), Saint-Petersbourg, 2005.
13. Dokinz R. Bog kak illjuzija (God as Illusion), Moscow, 2008.
14. Znamenskij P. V. Istorija Kazanskoj duhovnoj akademii za pervyj (doreformennyj) period ee sushhestvovanija (1842–1870 gg.) (History of Kazan Theological Academy in Its First Period (before Reform)), Kazan, 1892, vol. 2.
15. Kimelev Ju. A. Sovremennaja zapadnaja filosofija religii (Modern Western Philosophy of Religion), Moscow, 1989
16. Kimelev Ju. A. Filosofija religii: sistematicheskij ocherk (Philosophy of Religion: Systematic Essay), Moscow, 1998
17. Kudrjavcev-Platonov V. D. Sochinenija (Writings), Sergiev-Posad, 1898, vol. 2.
18. Lekcii po umozritel'nomu bogosloviju, so slov professora filosofii v MDA prot. F. A. Golubinskogo, zapisannye v 1841/2 uchebnom godu studentom Akademii XIV kursa V. Nazarevskim (Lectures on Speculative Theology by Prof. of Philosophy in Moscow Theological Academy Archpriest F. Golubinsky, written in 1841/1842 Year by the Student of Fourth Year, V. Nazarevsky). Moscow, 1868.
19. Mihail (Mud'jugin), arhiep. Vvedenie v osnovnoe bogoslovie (Introduction into Systematic Theology), Moscow, 1995.
20. Nikolin I. Kurs osnovnogo bogoslovija, ili Apologetiki (Course of Systematic Theology or Apologetics), Sergiev Posad, 1914.
21. Flint T. P., Rej M. K., Vasil'ev V. V. (ed.) Oksfordskoe rukovodstvo po filosofskoj teologii (Oxford Textbook for Philosophical Theology), Moscow, 2013, pp. 787–860
22. Osipov A. I. Put' razuma v poiskah istiny (The Way of Mind Looking for the Truth), Moscow, 2010
23. Osipov A. I. Put' razuma v poiskah istiny. Osnovnoe bogoslovie (The Way of Mind Looking for the Truth. Systematic Theology), Moscow, 1999
24. Rozhdestvenskij V. G., svjashh. Lekcii osnovnogo bogoslovija (Lectures on Systematic Theology), Saint-Petersbourg, 1883.
25. Rozhdestvenskij N. P. Hristianskaja apologetika. Kurs osnovnogo bogoslovija, chitannyj studentam v 1881/2 uchebnom godu. Posmertnoe izdanie SPB duhovnoj akademii (Christian Apologetics. Course of Systematic Theology Read in 1881/1882. Posthumous Edition of Saint-Petersbourg Theological Academy), Saint-Petersbourg, 1884, vol. 1.
26. Svetlov P. Ja., prot. Kurs apologeticheskogo bogoslovija (Course of Apologetics), Kiev, 1912.
27. Sergievskij N. Ob osnovnyh istinah hristianskoj very. Apologeticheskie publichnye chtenija, chitannye v 1871 g. (On Basic Verities of the Christian Faith. Apologetical Public Reading), Moscow, 1872.
28. Smirnov S. Istorija Moskovskoj duhovnoj akademii do ee preobrazovanija (1814–1870) (History of Moscow Theological Academy before Its Foundation (1814–1870)), Moscow, 1879.
29. Tihomirov D. A. Kurs osnovnogo bogoslovija (Course of Systematic Theology), Saint-Petersbourg, 1915.
30. Hlebnikov G. V. Filosofskaja teologija antichnosti: analiticheskij obzor (Philosophical Theology of the Ancient World: Analysis), Moscow, 2005.
31. Chistovich I. A. Sankt-Peterburgskaja duhovnaja akademija za poslednie 30 let (1858–1888) (Saint-Petersbourg Theological Academy in Last Thirty Years (1858–1888)), Saint-Petersbourg, 1889
32. Shohin V. K. Vvedenie v filosofiju religii (Introduction into Philosophy of Religion), Moscow, 2010.
33. Jevans S., Mjenis Z. Filosofija religii: razmyshlenie o vere (Philosophy of Religion: Thoughts about Faith), Moscow, 2011.

Information about the author

Shokhin Vladimir