The problem of “hellenisation of christianity” in the german theology and russian religious thought of the late 19th — early 20th centuries: prince S. N. Trubetskoy and A. von Harnak
Antonov Konstantin (2022)
"The problem of “hellenisation of christianity” in the german theology and russian religious thought of the late 19th — early 20th centuries: prince S. N. Trubetskoy and A. von Harnak ",
Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta.
Seriia I : Bogoslovie. Filosofiia. Religiovedenie
pp. 88-113 (in Russian).
DOI of the paper: 10.15382/sturI2022100.88-113
The article compares the philosophical-theological and historical-religious ideas and concepts of Prince S. N. Trubetskoi, a religious philosopher of the circle of V. S. Solovyov, a historian of philosophy and religion, and A. von Harnack, the largest representative of Protestant liberal theology of the second half of the 19th and early 20th centuries, famous for his concept of the "Hellenization of Christianity". The first part of the article establishes the basis for comparing the ideas of the two authors, identifies their starting points and preconditions, and discusses their place in the history of Christian thought in the context of the idea of religious crisis and the dialectic of confessionalization and deconfessionalization. Further, on the basis of recently published "Philosophical Correspondence" of the Trubetskoy brothers, the question of personal acquaintance of the thinkers and its role in the reception of Harnack's ideas in Russian thought is discussed. In the third part, the author reveals the elements of the positive reception of Harnack's ideas by Trubetskoi - on the basis of the data of the same Correspondence and the article "Ethics and dogmatics". The article points to Trubetskoy's perception of Harnack's critique of Orthodoxy, compares their understanding of the significance of historical research for philosophical and theological work, and their interpretation of the religious ideal of the kingdom of God.Part 4 outlines the main points of Trubetskoi's polemic with the German thinker - on the basis of the data from Correspondence, his article "Ethics and Dogmatics", and the major historical theological work of the philosopher, "Doctrine of the Logos in its History". The focus is on questions of Old Church Christology and the problem of the "Hellenization of Christianity," an argument related to the notion of the Jewish origin of Gnosticism. The author emphasizes the significant role of V. Solov'ev's personality and ideas in shaping Trubetskoi's attitude toward Harnack. In conclusion, general conclusions are made about the relationship between Trubetskoi's and Harnack's ideas and about the role of the reception of the German theologian's ideas in the formation of Trubetskoi's own position and the history of Russian religious thought as a whole.
S. N. Trubetskoi, A. von Harnack, V. Solov'ev, philosophical theology, Hellenization of Christianity, Gnosticism, Logos, Dogma, Dogmengeschichte
- Antonov K. (2020) Kak vozmozhna religiia?″ Filosofi ia religii i fi losofskie problemy bogosloviia v russkoi religioznoi mysli XIX — XX vekov [“How is religion possible?”: philosophy of religion and philosophical problems of theology in Russian religious thought of the 19th — 20th centuries]. Moscow: PSTGU (in Russian).
- Ermishina Ks. (ed.) (2021) Filosofskaia perepiska brat′ev Trubetskikh. Iz arkhiva kniagini Ol′gi Nikolaevny Trubetskoi [The philosophical correspondence of the Trubetskoi brothers. From the archives of Princess Olga Nikolaevna Trubetskaya]. Moscow (in Russian).
- Ern V. (1991) “Metody istoricheskogo issledovaniia i kniga Garnaka Sushchnost′ khristianstva″” [Methods of historical research and Harnack’s Essence of Christianity], in Sochineniia [Works], Moscow, pp. 245–264 (in Russian).
- Gaidenko P. (1994) “Konkretnyi idealizm″ S.N. Trubetskogo” [“Concrete idealism” of S.N. Trubetskoi], in S.N. Trubetskoi, Sochineniia, Moscow, pp. 3–42 (in Russian).
- Harnak A. (2001) “Das Wesen des Christentums”, in Rannee khristianstvo [Early Christianity], vol. 1, Moscow, pp. 9–180 (Russian translation).
- Harnak A. (2001) “Dogmengeschichte”, in Rannee khristianstvo [Early Christianity], vol. 2, Moscow, pp. 87–508 (Russian translation).
- Harnak A. (2009) “Fünfzehn Fragen an die Verächter der wissenschaftlichen Theologie unter den Theologen”, in Sravnitel′noe bogoslovie: nemetskii protestantizm XX veka. Teksty s kommentariiami [Comparative theology: German Protestantism of the 20th century. Texts with commentary]. Moscow: PSTGU, pp. 154–156 (Russian transtlation).
- Kozyrev A. (2007) Solov’ev i gnostiki [Solovyov and the Gnostics]. Moscow (in Russian).
- Miroshnikov I. (2010) “Iudeiskie istoki gnostitsizma. S.N. Trubetskoi i sovremennoe religiovedenie” [Jewish origins of Gnosticism. S.N. Trubetskoi and modern religious studies], in Antichnost′ i kul′tura Serebrianogo veka: K 85-letiiu A.A. Takho-Godi [Antiquity and the culture of the Silver Age: For the 85th anniversary of A.A. Takho-Godi]. Moscow, pp. 434–441 (in Russian).
- Orekhanov G. (2016) Lev Tolstoi. “Prorok bez chesti”: khronika katastrofy [Leo Tolstoy. “A prophet without honour”: a chronicle of disaster]. Moscow (in Russian).
- Pylaev M. (2014) “Dogmengeschichte″ A. fon Garnaka i liberal′no-teologicheskaia kontseptsiia ellinizatsii khristianstva” [Adolf von Harnack’s Dogmengeschichte and the liberal theological concept of the Hellenisation of Christianity], in Religiovedcheskie issledovaniia, vol. 1–2 (9–10), pp. 86–101 (in Russian).
- Pylaev M. (2021) Filosofskie nachala nemetskoiazychnoi teologii XIX–XX vekov [Philosophical foundations of German-language theology in the 19th and 20th centuries]. Moscow: PSTGU (in Russian).
- Rumiantseva M. (2015) “Kompensatornaia teoriia v rabotakh Germanna Liubbe i Odo Markvarda” [Compensatory theory in the works of Hermann Lübbe and Odo Marquard]. Vestnik Leningradskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta imeni A. S. Pushkina, vol. 2 (1), pp. 140–150 (in Russian).
- Solov′ev A. (2022) “Russkaia religioznaia filosofiia XIX — pervoi poloviny XX vv. v kontekste istorii religii: ot religioznoi konversii k kul′tur-kritike i konfessionalizatsii” [Russian religious philosophy in the 19th and the First Half of the 20th centuries in the context of the history of religion: from religious conversion to cultural criticism and confessionalisation]. Trudy kafedry bogosloviia Sankt-Peterburgskoi Dukhovnoi Akademii, vol. 1 (13), pp. 1–17 (in Russian).
- Solov′ev Vl. (1988) “Opravdanie dobra” [The justifi cation of the good], in Sochineniia [Works], vol. 1, Moscow, pp. 47–580 (in Russian).
- Solov′ev Vl. (1989) “Chteniia o Bogochelovechestve” [Lectures on Godmanhood], in Sochineniia [Works], vol. 2, Moscow, pp. 5–174 (in Russian).
- Trubetskoi S. (1994) “Uchenie o Logose v ego istorii” [The doctrine of the Logos in its history”], in Sochineniia [Works], Moscow, pp. 43–482 (in Russian).
Information about the author
Antonov Konstantin Academic Degree:
Doctor of Sciences*
in Philosophy; Academic Rank:
Associate Professor; Place of work:
St. Tikhon's Orthodox University for Humanities; 6/1 Lihov per., Moscow, 127051 Russian Federation; Post:
Head of the Department of Philosophy and religious studies; ORCID: 0000-0003-0982-2513
*According to ISCED 2011, a post-doctoral degree called Doctor of Sciences (D.Sc.) is given to reflect second advanced research qualifications or higher doctorates.
This article was supported by RFBR Grant No. 21-011-44030, "Thinking of Being and Belief in Revelation: Paths of Correlation in German-Speaking Protestant Theology and Russian Religious Philosophy in the 20th Century.