/
Search results


Павлюткина Е. Л. [Review] // Вестник ПСТГУ. Серия I: Богословие. Философия. 2012. Вып. 6 (44). С. 145-148. — Rev. op.: Welfare and Religion in 21st Century Europe. Volume 1: Configuring the Connections / A. Bäckström, G. Davie, eds. Farnham; Burlington: Ashgate, 2010. 242 P. Welfare and Religion in 21St Century Europe. Volume 2
PDF
Павлюткин И. В. [Review] // Вестник ПСТГУ. Серия I: Богословие. Философия. 2013. Вып. 6 (50). С. 138-141. — Rev. op.: Higton M. A. Theology of Higher Education. Oxford University Press, 2012
PDF
Емельянов Н. Н., Павлюткин И. В. Университет и дар: постановка проблемы // Вестник ПСТГУ. Серия I: Богословие. Философия. 2014. Вып. 6 (56). С. 21-37. DOI: 10.15382/sturI201456.21-37
The authors suggest introducing the notion of the gift into the theory and practice of the University life. They believe that the relationship of gift in transmission of knowledge is immanent to the management organization of the University. If knowledge is given as a gift and in the situation of gift-giving, then the University milieu should have the relationship of gift. The gift is described here as a theological and anthropological category and then juxtaposed with educational concepts of certain theologians and with ideas of modern economists. Proceeding from the notion of gift, the authors formulate the problem of today’s University which consists in its economical conditionality and in the penetration of market ideology into the scholarly milieu. Transfer of knowledge, which is considered as an absolute value, when circulating within the process of gift-giving, in practice is often identified with utilitarian exchange: the knowledge acquires its price, what inevitably reflects the relationship between professors, students and University’s administration.
gift, University, knowledge, theology, economy, higher education theology, market, community, J. H. Newman, formal organization.

1. Becker G. S. 1962 “Investment in human capital: A theoretical analysis”, in Journal of Political Economy, 1962, vol. 70/5/2, pp. 9–49.
2. Clark B. R. 1972 “The Organizational Saga in Higher Education”, in Administrative Science Quarterly, 1972, vol. 17/2, pp. 178–184.
3. Derrida J. 1992 “Donner la mort”, in L’éthique du don. Cоlloque de Royaumont, Paris, 1992.
4. Derrida J. Donner le temps. 1. La fausse monnaie, Paris, 1991.
5. Derrida J. Foi et savoir, suivi par Le siècle et le pardon, Paris, 2000.
6. Derrida J. L’impardonnable et l’imprescriptible, Paris, 2005.
7. Frey B. S. 2003 “Publishing as prostitution? — Choosing between one’s own ideas and academic success”, in Public Choice, 2003, vol. 116, pp. 205–223.
8. Gregory C. Gifts and Commodities, London; New York, 1982.
9. Higton M. A. Theology of Higher Education, New York, 2012.
10. Krücken G., Meier F. 2006 “Turning the University into an Organizational Actor”, in Drori G. S., Meyer J. W., Hwang H. (eds.) Globalization and Organization, Oxford, 2006, pp. 241–257.
11. Marion J.-L. Au lieu de soi. L’approche de Saint Augustin, Paris, 2008.
12. Melkumyan E., Prutskova E., Pavlyutkin I. 2014 “Religiosity, Social Capital and Civic Engagement: Cluster Effects on Russian Undergraduate Programs”, in Paper presented in track 5 at the EAIR 36th Annual Forum in Essen, Germany 27–30 August 2014, in http://eairaww.websites.xs4all.nl/forum/essen/PDF/1514.pdf (Date: 23.10.2014)).
13. Milbank J. Being Reconciled: Ontology and Pardon, London, 2003.
14. Ramirez F. O. 2006 “The Rationalization of Universities”, in Djelic M.-L., Shalin-Andersson K. (eds.) Transnational Governance: Institutional Dynamics of Regulation, Cambridge 2006, pp. 225–244.
15. Webb S. H. The Gifting God: A Trinitarian Ethics of Excess, New York, 1996.
16. Blaug M. Jekonomicheskaja mysl' v retrospective (Economic Thought in Retrospective), Moscow, 1994.
17. Godel'e M. Zagadka dara (Puzzle of Gift), Moscow, 2007.
18. Dajmond A. M., ml. 2007 “Povedenie universitetov i uchenyh: jekonomicheskie ob’jasnenija” (Behavior of Universities and Scholars: Economic Explanation), in Semenova M. V. (ed.) Jekonomika universiteta: instituty i organizacii, Moscow, 2007, pp. 8–48.
19. Dimadzhio P., Paujell U. V. 2010 “Novyj vzgljad na «zheleznuju kletku»: institucional'nyj izomorfizm i kollektivnaja racional'nost' v organizacionnyh poljah” (New View on “Iron Cage”: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organisation Fields), in Jekonomicheskaja sociologija, 2010, vol. 11/1, pp. 34–56.
20. Doroga k akademicheskomu sovershenstvu: Stanovlenie issledovatel'skih universitetov mirovogo klassa / F. Dzh. Al'tbah, Dzh. Salmi, per. M., 2012.
21. Emel'janov N. N., Melkumjan E. B., Pavljutkin I. V. Pravoslavnyj universitet i obshhestvo v Rossii. Vypuskniki pravoslavnogo universiteta: povedenie, cennosti, ustanovki (Orthodox University and Society in Russia. Alumni of Orthodox University: Behavior, Values, Puttings), Moscow, 2013.
22. Zabaev I. V., Pavljutkin I. V. 2014 “Universitet i dva znachenija otvetstvennosti: ob’ektivacija obshhestvennyh jeffektov obrazovatel'nyh institutov (na primere oprosa vypusknikov pravoslavnogo universiteta)” (University and Two Meanings of Responsibility: Objectivation of Social Effects of Educational Institutions), in Voprosy obrazovanija, 2014, vol. 2, pp. 202–221.
23. Kallist Dioklijskij, ep. 1997 “Svjashhennoe Pisanie i svjatye Otcy o bogoslovskom obrazovanii” (Saint Scripture and Holy Fathers about Theological Education), in Bogoslovskij sbornik, Moscow, 1997, vol. 1, pp. 142–152.
24. Mejendorf I., protopr. 2013 “Pravoslavnoe bogoslovie segodnja” (Orthodox Theology Today), in Pashal'naja tajna. Stat'i po bogosloviju, Moscow, 2013, pp. 712–730.
25. Mejendorf I., protopr. 2013 “Svet s Vostoka? «Bogoslovstvovanie» v perspektive Vostochnogo hristianstva” (Ex Oriente Lux? “Theology” in Perspective of Eastern Christianity), in Pashal'naja tajna. Stat'i po bogosloviju, Moscow, 2013, pp. 745–764.
26. Mejer D., Roujen B. 2011 “Institucionalizirovannye organizacii: formal'naja struktura kak mif i ceremonial” (Institutioned Organizations: Formal Structure as Myth and Ceremonial), in Jekonomicheskaja sociologija, 2011, vol. 12/1, pp. 43–67.
27. Merton R. Social'naja teorija i social'naja struktura (Social Theory and Social Structure), Moscow, 2006.
28. Nussbaum M. Ne radi pribyli: Zachem demokratii nuzhny gumanitarnye nauki (Not for Profit: Why Do Democracy Need Humanitarian Sciences), Moscow, 2014.
29. N'jumen Dzh. G. Ideja universiteta (Idea of Univerisity), Minsk, 2006.
30. 2011 “O Dare. Diskussija mezhdu Zh. Derrida i Zh.-L. Marionom” (About Gift: Discussion between J. Derrida and J.-L. Marion), in Logos, 2011, vol. 3/82, pp. 144–171.
31. Pavljutkin I. V. 2012 “Preodolevaja granicy mezhdu gosudarstvom i cerkov'ju: sluchaj pravoslavnogo universiteta” (Overcoming of Frontiers between State and Church: Case of Orthodox University), in Jetnograficheskoe obozrenie, 2012, vol. 3, pp. 47–64.
32. Pavljutkin I. V. 2011 “Konstruirovanie universiteta kak organizacii” (Constructing of University as Organization), in Jekonomicheskaja sociologija, 2011, vol. 12/1, pp. 104–123.
33. Radaev V. V. 2010 “Pjat' principov postroenija novogo universiteta” (Five Principles of Formation of New University), in Pro et contra, 2010, vol. 14/3, pp. 6–18.
34. Ridings B. Universitet v ruinah (University in Ruins), Moscow, 2010.
35. Ssorin-Chajkov N. V. 2012 “Medvezh'ja shkura i makarony: o social'noj zhizni veshhej v sibirskom sovhoze i performativnosti razlichij dara i tovara” (Bear Skin and Noodle: about Social Life of Things in Siberian Sovkhoz), in Jekonomicheskaja sociologija, 2012, vol. 13/2, pp. 59–81.
36. Frumin I. D. 2012 “Sozdanie novogo issledovatel'skogo universiteta: Nacional'nyj issledovatel'skij universitet «Vysshaja shkola jekonomiki», Rossija” (Making of New Research University: National Research University “High School of Economics”, Russia), in Doroga k akademicheskomu sovershenstvu: Stanovlenie issledovatel'skih universitetov mirovogo klassa, Moscow, 2012, pp. 309–340.
37. Jerenberg R. G. 2007 “Teorija Adama Smita i universitety: jekonomist stanovitsja upravljajushhim vuza” (Theory of Adam Smith and Universities: Economist Becomes High School Manager), in Semenova M. V. (ed.) Jekonomika universiteta: instituty i organizacii, Moscow, 2007, pp. 78–107.
Emel'ianov Nikolai, archpriest
Pavliutkin Ivan