Foundations of education in the USA and Russia: cultural and religious perspectives
Loginova Marina (2019)
"Foundations of education in the USA and Russia: cultural and religious perspectives ",
Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Sviato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta.
Seriia IV : Pedagogika. Psihologiia
pp. 9-23 (in Russian).
DOI of the paper: 10.15382/sturIV201954.9-23
This article deals with the history of the systems of education in the USA and Russia as well as with the connection between education and religion. The comparison of the requirements for the educational process that have formed in the two cultures throughout the history allows one to speak about the diff erences in the national systems of Russian and American education. The article examines some studies of those researchers who dealt with the connection between culture and religion as well as with the history of the development of national educational systems and addresses to the core religions of the USA and Russia, i.e. Protestantism and Orthodoxy. The article studies certain key characteristics, mindsets, and values of the Protestant and Orthodox religions that shape the educational cultures of the USA and Russia. Among the characteristics under comparison, there are vocation of the person, labour in the person’s life, and the attitude to the result of his or her labour. These features are closely connected to the process of education and infl uence its ideology. This comparison, as well as the linguistic and etymological analysis of the words education and образование, to bring up, воспитывать allows one to conclude that the meaning of education is diff erent in the two cultures. Major aims of the education in these countries have national peculiarities and sometimes are fundamentally dissimilar, which makes one doubt the unreasonable transfer of any important feature from one educational culture to the other.
national system of education, history of education, educational (academic) values, Protestant values, Orthodox values, educational traditions of USA, educational traditions of Russia
- “Education for All American Youth” (1944), in Educational Policies Commission. Washington.
- “The Purposes of Education in American Democracy” (1938), in Educational Policies Commission. Washington, pp. 102–103.
- Barrow C. (1990) Universities and the Capitalist State. Corporate Liberalism and the Reconstruction of American Higher Education, 1894–1928. Madison.
- Belenchuk L. (2018) “Traditsionalizm v russkoy pedagogike rubezha XIX‒XX vv. (na primere tvorchestva K. P. Pobedonostseva i o. Ioanna Kronshtadtskogo)” [Traditionalism in Russian Pedagogy of the Late 19th — Early 20th Centuries (with Konstantin Pobedonostsev’s and St. Ioann Kronshtadtskiy’s Literary Works as an Example)]. Vestnik PSTGU. Seriia IV: Pedagogika. Psihologiya, 49, pp. 49–58 (in Russian).
- Bok D. (1990) Universities and the Future of America. Durham; London.
- Bondarevskaia E., Kulnevich S. (1999) Pedagogika: lichnost v gumanisticheskikh teoriyakh i sistemakh vospitaniya [Pedagogy: The Personality in Humanistic Theories and Systems of Upbringing]. Moscow (in Russian).
- Dal V. (2011) Tolkovyi slovar' zhivogo velikorusskogo iazyka [Explanatory Dictionary of the Living Great Russian Language]. Moscow, vol. 2 (in Russian).
- Delbanco A. (2014) College. What It Was, Is, and Should Be. Berlin; Boston.
- Divnogortseva S. (2006) “Smysl, sushchnost' i tsel' vospitaniia v kontekste pravoslavnoi pedagogicheskoi kul'tury” [Meaning, Essence, and Goals of Education in the Context of Orthodox Culture]. Vestnik PSTGU. Ser. 4: Pedagogika. Psihologiya, 3, pp. 68–87 (in Russian).
- Divnogortseva S. (2009) “Filosofsko-istoricheskoe obosnovanie idealov vospitaniia v trudakh slavianofi lov” [Philosophical and Historical Grounds of Pedagogical Ideas in Works of Slavophiles]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta MVD Rossii, 4, pp. 11–15 (in Russian).
- Dushepoleznye poucheniia prepodobnykh Optinskikh startsev (2003) [Edifying Homilies of the Holy Elders of Optina Monastery], in 2 vols. Vol. 2. Izdanie Vvedenskoi Optinoi pustyni (in Russian).
- Franklin B. (1993) Autobiography. Boston.
- Hillescheim J., Merrill G. (1971) Theory and Practice in the History of American Education. A Book of Readings. Pacific Palisades.
- Ignatii (Brianchaninov), St. (2007). Otechnik [Selected Sayings of Saint Fathers]. St. Petersburg (in Russian).
- Ilarion (Alfeev), metropolitan. (2012) Pravoslaviie [Orthodoxy], vol. 1. Moscow (in Russian).
- Lucas C. (2006) American Higher Education. A History. New York.
- Osipov A. Vstrecha s dukhovenstvom [Meeting with the Clergy], available at http://tv-soyuz.ru/peredachi/a-i-osipov-vstrecha-s-duhovenstvom-chast-1 (in Russian, 01.09.2019).
- Osipov A. Chto takoe obrazovanie? [What does Education Mean?], available at https://alexey-osipov.ru/video/obrazovanie/chto-takoe-obrazovanie-mpgu-20140517/ (in Russian, 01.09.2019).
- Pirogov N. (2016) Izbrannye pedagogicheskie proizvedeniia [Selected Pedagogical Works]. Moscow (in Russian).
- Rapatsevich E. (2010) Zolotaia kniga pedagoga [Golden Book of the Educationalist]. Minsk (in Russian).
- Rosenstock-Huessy E. (1938) Out of Revolution. Autobiography of Western Man. New York.
- Rushdoony R. (1963) The Messianic Character of American Education. Studies in the history of the philosophy of education. Nutley.
- Teliia V. (1996) Russkaia frazeologiia. Semanticheskii, pragmaticheskii i lingvokul'turologicheskii aspekty [Russian Phraseology. Semantic, Pragmatic, and Lingvo-Cultural Aspects]. Moscow (in Russian).
- Thelin J. (2004) A History of American Education. Baltimore.
- Vasmer M. (1964‒1973) Etimologicheskii slovar' russkogo iazyka [Etymological Dictionary of Russian]. Moscow (Russian translation).
- Vine P. (1976) “The Social Function of Eighteen-Century Higher Education”. History of Education Quarterly, 16/4, pp. 409–424.
- Weber M. (2016) Protestantskaia etika i dukh kapitalizma [The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism]. Moscow; St. Petersburg (Russian translation).
Information about the author
Loginova Marina Place of work:
Bates College; Lewiston, Maine, USA; Post:
Visiting Lecturer, Department of German and Russian Studies; ORCID: 0000-0003-4772-1748